Frank J. Avella
The Contending
Sep 20, 2026
B-
Pitt seems to be playing Achilles as if he were living in 2004 (the film’s release year) but he’s still fun to watch. The only actor who does his damndest to take things seriously is the extraordinary O’Toole as Priam...
Go to Full Review
Mitchell Beaupre
Paste Magazine
May 15, 2024
7.5/10
Troy puts immense care into every single beat of its action, and as a result these sequences drive its emotions in a way the script often fails to achieve
Go to Full Review
Steve Warren
Southern Voice (Atlanta)
May 7, 2023
3/4
In terms of historical accuracy, Troy is probably on par with Van Helsing. But for balancing intimate stories with spectacular battles in an old-school-sized epic, it's closer to Gladiator.
Go to Full Review
Sean Axmaker
Stream on Demand
Jul 5, 2022
... it’s hard to take the cataclysmic events of this ancient war seriously, as it is entirely predicated on an unconvincing romantic gesture of a prince with the impulse control of a spoiled brat and the political consideration of a cat in heat.
Go to Full Review
Robin Holabird
Robin Holabird
Aug 11, 2021
Petersen puts an effects-generated, action-film spin on the Trojan War, focusing on spectacle rather than emotional nuance. While this undermines acting opportunities by downplaying personalities, it works on a popcorn entertainment level.
Go to Full Review
Ellie Lucas
The Dispatch (Lexington, NC)
Jun 5, 2019
2/4
With all the over-the-top costumes and sets, it looks more like a television movie of the week than a big summer event flick.
Go to Full Review
Daniel Mendelsohn
The New York Review of Books
Aug 20, 2018
The real problem with Petersen and Benioff's reductive ideological updating of the epic story they tell is organic, not pedantic: the "realism" they've opted for goes against the grain of the genre they're working in.
Go to Full Review
Will Self
London Evening Standard
Jan 9, 2018
Brad is worth the ticket price alone and others turned in creditable performances, particularly Eric Bana as an upright family man who just happens to be the prince of a warlike city-state, and Sean Bean as Odysseus the Ironic.
Go to Full Review
Kevin Carr
Fat Guys at the Movies
Jan 17, 2016
2.5/5
overblown historical epic
Go to Full Review
Tim Brayton
Antagony & Ecstasy
Dec 4, 2014
4/10
An adaptation of The Iliad that would have had to work much harder to miss the point of The Iliad any more thoroughly.
Go to Full Review
Nell Minow
Common Sense Media
Dec 29, 2010
3/5
Violent, watered-down version of The Iliad.
Go to Full Review
Felix Vasquez Jr.
Cinema Crazed
Apr 29, 2009
While an achievement in visuals, Troy fails in every other aspect including its writing and storytelling.
Go to Full Review
Urban Cinefile Critics
Urban Cinefile
Oct 18, 2008
Despite its shortcomings, Troy is a visual smorgasbord.
Go to Full Review
Rob Gonsalves
Rob's Movie Vault
Aug 5, 2007
B+
The face-off between Achilles and Hector is beautifully realized, all the more wounding because we can precisely read each man's emotions going into the fight.
Go to Full Review
Joe Lozito
Big Picture Big Sound
Jul 14, 2007
1/4
It's coherent at least. But only barely. Its special effects are pretty, and it has a cool soundtrack (though it's over-used). But boy is the writing terrible. I mean, terrible.
Go to Full Review
Kam Williams
Princeton Town Topics
May 2, 2007
2/4
All the cast members, even Mr. Pitt, adopt the obligatory British accent, sans contractions, employed by the historical drama genre, even though the action takes place in Ancient Greece.
Go to Full Review
Jessica Winter
Time Out
Jun 24, 2006
A numbingly reliable tick-tock of expository set pieces alternating with vast CGI-aided battle scenes.
Go to Full Review
Uri Lessing
www.kcactive.com
Jul 25, 2005
2/5
Troy condenses Homer's ten-year war into a couple of months.
Go to Full Review
Jason Zingale
Bullz-Eye.com
Jul 5, 2005
3/5
The battle of Troy takes the jump from history books to film with little consideration, disregarding the story's historical accuracy and failing to entertain audiences with the kind of flashy battle sequences the summer season demands.
Go to Full Review
Brian Juergens
Freeze Dried Movies
Apr 1, 2005
6/10
Aside from being the first Hair Movie of the year, Troy also claims the prize of being the first Get Your Fat Butt to the Gym Movie of the year.
Go to Full Review