Tom Cassidy
Common Sense Media
Dec 2, 2021
2/5
Adapted from an award-winning novel that no doubt gave the time and space for its characters to breathe, the movie fails to give any emotional weight to those on screen.
Go to Full Review
Tom Bond
One Room With A View
Mar 5, 2019
3/5
In the end the plot falls back on melodramatic clichés of forbidden love.
Go to Full Review
Stephen Saito
Moveable Fest
Nov 1, 2018
In even the smallest expressions of this freedom, whether it's a rare grin from Mara or Redgrave playing a few bars of "Moonlight Sonata," "The Secret Scripture" soars.
Go to Full Review
Ailbhe O'Reilly
Film Ireland Magazine
Mar 23, 2018
On a positive note, Rooney Mara is a very talented actress and is as captivating as ever in the film - Bana and Redgrave also do their best with the material, but the strong cast is not enough to rescue this dud of an adaptation from Sheridan.
Go to Full Review
Jim Schembri
3AW
Dec 13, 2017
3/5
Fine, lush-looking, understated 2016 wartime drama from veteran Jim Sheridan...Perfect arthouse fare, this.
Go to Full Review
Stephen Romei
The Australian
Dec 8, 2017
3/5
This is a honourable film that has hits and misses. Watch it for the performances, particularly Redgrave's. Its most telling line is this: Bravery in the face of the enemy
Go to Full Review
Sandra Hall
Sydney Morning Herald
Dec 8, 2017
4/5
The Secret Scripture is a highly streamlined adaptation of Sebastian Barry's 2008 Man Booker finalist.
Go to Full Review
Graeme Tuckett
The Post NZ
Dec 7, 2017
1.5/5
... all the window dressing in the world isn't enough to hide the fact that this misbegotten load of old tosh really doesn't add up to a coherent or credible yarn. Avoid.
Go to Full Review
Vicky Roach
Daily Telegraph (Australia)
Dec 6, 2017
2/5
A minor disappointment.
Go to Full Review
JosĂ© MartĂn
El antepenĂşltimo mohicano
Oct 25, 2017
2/5
... a new missed opportunity to regain the respect of critics and the public. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Todd Jorgenson
Cinemalogue
Oct 13, 2017
As the mystery unfolds, the film gradually strains credibility and becomes more formulaic in structure.
Go to Full Review
Matthew Bond
The Mail on Sunday (UK)
Oct 11, 2017
3/5
Mara and Redgrave are beautifully cast and extremely good in the central role. But you do need to be up with your Anglo-Irish history and you may find the last lap as contrived as it is sentimental.
Go to Full Review
Matt Wolf
The Arts Desk
May 19, 2017
1/5
Sheridan's adaptation of Sebastian Barry's Man Booker-shortlisted novel begins portentously and spirals downwards from there.
Go to Full Review
Josh Slater-Williams
Little White Lies
May 19, 2017
2/5
Its lack of nuance and persistent plotting issues frequently undermine much of the potential emotional heft.
Go to Full Review
Lisa Giles-Keddie
HeyUGuys
May 19, 2017
3/5
The overall power of the story is female suppression across the ages that really hits home - subtly interwoven, but accompanied by that unsavoury feel of demonising the independent screen female again.
Go to Full Review
Stephen Carty
Radio Times
May 18, 2017
3/5
Mara ensures that we feel for Rose, and James is surprisingly effective as the man who ruins Rose's life, but The Secret Scripture isn't as moving or intriguing as it should be.
Go to Full Review
Allan Hunter
Daily Express (UK)
May 18, 2017
3/5
The result is still a handsome romantic epic but it lacks the emotional punch of the book.
Go to Full Review
Kevin Maher
The Times (UK)
May 18, 2017
1/5
Sebastian Barry's Costa prizewinning novel is gutted and reconstituted to the point of absurdity in this cockeyed adaptation.
Go to Full Review
Robbie Collin
Daily Telegraph (UK)
May 18, 2017
2/5
Variously lukewarm and lugubrious ...
Go to Full Review
Geoffrey Macnab
Independent (UK)
May 17, 2017
2/5
It's the construction, not the performances, which undermines The Secret Scripture.
Go to Full Review