Don Shanahan
Every Movie Has a Lesson
Oct 18, 2024
3/5
Without becoming a version of John Wayne and Katharine Hepburn from “Rooster Cogburn” as a blustering and bickering mismatched pair, both Jones and Swank stay true to the hardscrabble roots needed for this story
Go to Full Review
Diego Batlle
Otroscines.com
Apr 12, 2023
4/5
The Homesman is a beautiful film that brings a rarely seen female (and feminist) perspective to the stories of the Old West. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Richard Crouse
Richard Crouse
Feb 2, 2021
2/5
Muddier than the rough terrain it takes place on.
Go to Full Review
Mike Massie
Gone With The Twins
Dec 4, 2020
6/10
Tommy Lee Jones is completely at home in the role of a cantankerous, frank, gruff, and grizzled cowboy.
Go to Full Review
Debbie Lynn Elias
Behind The Lens
Dec 14, 2019
A masterful, fully sensory experience filled with visual majesty, immersing us in the life and lives of the time.
Go to Full Review
Nicholas Bell
IONCINEMA.com
Sep 12, 2019
2/5
While it may afford us with a rare perspective of women's experiences in such a time and place, the film's narrative manages to appear misogynistic even as it appears to be developing an argument for agency.
Go to Full Review
Alberto AbuĂn
Espinof
Sep 4, 2019
While maintaining a very obvious respect for the genre, the film is terribly current for several reasons. [Full Review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Ellie Lucas
The Dispatch (Lexington, NC)
Jul 5, 2019
3/4
A defiant rejection of genre cliché with a resonance that is hard to shake.
Go to Full Review
Stephen O'Nion
One Room With A View
May 31, 2019
3/5
When it works, beautiful and bestial.
Go to Full Review
John Bleasdale
CineVue
Apr 3, 2019
4/5
With The Homesman, Jones has produced an original and cantankerously offbeat western which becomes increasingly beguiling as the road stretches on.
Go to Full Review
Erik Anderson
Awards Watch
Aug 27, 2018
It feels like a missed opportunity but there is still quite a bit to enjoy.
Go to Full Review
Michael Smith
Tulsa World
Feb 16, 2018
3/4
The Homesman is a dark, complex story of gender issues and changing conventions on the frontier, and in an era that sees this genre fading, Jones has made a Western winner.
Go to Full Review
Matthew Bond
The Mail on Sunday (UK)
Oct 30, 2017
Hilary Swank gives a particularly good central performance -- but the end result is a real curate's egg: too much at times, underdeveloped at others and marred by a huge plot twist that stops the story almost in its tracks.
Go to Full Review
M. Faust
The Public (Buffalo)
Oct 18, 2017
It's a film worth seeing before the crowd of Oscar contenders sweeps it out of the way for the holiday season.
Go to Full Review
Lisa Rosman
Signature
Aug 3, 2017
Clear-eyed but never discompassionate, The Homesman collects uneasy truths that are all too often left by the wayside of our nation's road to success.
Go to Full Review
Eleanor Ringel Cater
Saporta Report (Atlanta)
Jun 28, 2017
As a director, he's batted it out of the park. Twice. First with the eloquent and little-seen The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada and now with the hardscrabble brilliance of The Homesman.
Go to Full Review
Mark Jackson
Epoch Times
Jun 13, 2016
2.5/5
A fair portion of Tommy Lee's life has been dedicated to telling stories about schlepping variously incapacitated or dead people long distances through the Wild West.
Go to Full Review
Jason Bailey
Flavorwire
Jun 7, 2016
If 'The Homesman' proves anything, it's that there's no movie that can't get a shot in the arm from a couple scenes of Tommy Lee Jones hollerin' and dancin'.
Go to Full Review
Peter Labuza
The Film Stage
Jun 6, 2016
C
If Jones wants to become a great director of a dying genre, he cannot simply hope to mimic what the masters did. He must instead explore the meaning of each image he creates.
Go to Full Review
Robert W. Butler
Kansas City Star
Nov 19, 2015
3.5/4
With his sophomore effort, The Homesman, Jones gives us a revisionist Western that defies expectations at every turn. It's a genuine art film in the vein of Aussie productions like The Proposition.
Go to Full Review