Carson Timar
ClapperCast
Mar 15, 2026
The Great Ziegfeld fails to capture either spectacle or substance, dragging its feet with a clear lack of passion or love for the story it is telling.
Go to Full Review
Matt Brunson
Film Frenzy
Jan 9, 2024
2.5/4
A real curio of a film, it soars in spots and staggers in others.
Go to Full Review
Christopher Lloyd
The Film Yap
Dec 25, 2023
3.5/5
The 1936 Best Picture Oscar winner is surely an extravaganza of stage splendor, and William Powell charms as the impresario who knew the highest of highs and lowest of lows.
Go to Full Review
Mark Johnson
Awards Daily
Jun 27, 2023
A nearly 3-hour film with big set pieces and over a thousand people employed, The Great Ziegfeld is far too long for a musical romp.
Go to Full Review
E. L. Espectador
Cinelandia
Sep 1, 2022
First place amongst those of its kind. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Pauline Kael
The New Yorker
Jul 28, 2022
Fanny Brice is herself, though she isn't on screen enough to vitalize this lavish, tedious musical biography; it goes on for a whopping three hours, but through some insane editing decision she's cut off in the middle of singing "My Man."
Go to Full Review
Eduardo Guaitsel
Cine-Mundial
Jul 1, 2022
A work that dazzles, and is decidedly a smash hit wherever it goes. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Otis Ferguson
The New Republic
Feb 18, 2022
Too glib for real life, it is persuasive for all that -- possibly just because of that.
Go to Full Review
Ruth Lewis
Austin American-Statesman
Dec 3, 2021
For the greater part, The Great Ziegfeld is sentiment; for the remainder, spectacle. It is an unbeatable combination and MGM has seen fit to give it a more substantial claim in good casting.
Go to Full Review
Mark Van Doren
The Nation
Dec 3, 2021
Few films have been more lavish than this one... but since it can be doubted that Ziegfeld was either the Shakespeare or the Leonardo he is represented to have been, it can also be doubted that the money was well spent.
Go to Full Review
C.A. Lejeune
Observer (UK)
Dec 3, 2021
I think that three hours and five minutes is too long for any picture. The Great Ziegfeld suffers, too, from the fact that its most exciting sequence comes plumb in the middle.
Go to Full Review
P.S. Harrison
Harrison's Reports
Dec 2, 2021
There is no picture to equal it for lavishness, beauty, and all-around entertainment; and not once during the three hours that it runs does it become boresome.
Go to Full Review
Robert Herring
Guardian
Dec 2, 2021
The representation of this greatness is done with such consistent loud-pedalling that the picture lacks climax as much as it needs relief.
Go to Full Review
MPH Staff
Motion Picture Herald (Exhibitors Herald)
Dec 2, 2021
In comparison, no previous music dance spectacle, no matter how elaborately produced, approaches it from a standpoint of sheer brilliance and beauty.
Go to Full Review
Marion Aitchison
Tampa Bay Times
Dec 2, 2021
It is brilliant and spectacular to a superlative degree with scenes that are nothing less than astonishing in their magnificence.
Go to Full Review
Landon Laird
Kansas City Star
Dec 2, 2021
It is a great picturization of the career of an unforgettable figure in the American theater.
Go to Full Review
Mae Tinée
Chicago Tribune
Dec 2, 2021
For sheer lavishness, attention to detail, honesty of purpose, The Great Ziegfeld is to be commended. Where the picture falls down -- hard! -- is in its fulsomeness.
Go to Full Review
John Marks
Sight & Sound
Dec 2, 2021
Of course, it's swell to look at -- or swollen -- like a glorified goldfish; but then, if you examine it, its tail falls right off. One might perhaps keep it in a glass case -- which is more than you could do with this dead whale here.
Go to Full Review
Ian Coster
London Evening Standard
Dec 2, 2021
Luise Rainer, the Viennese actress, is a risen star as Ziegfeld's first wife, Anna Held. Gay as a butterfly, temperamental as an April day, she is the outstanding actress in the film.
Go to Full Review
Winston Burdett
Brooklyn Daily Eagle
Dec 2, 2021
Though it is a flattering tribute to the taste of the late showman, The Great Ziegfeld is also an apt one, for it has the same combination of gaudiness and elegance, of show and finish, which you associate with a good "Follies."
Go to Full Review