The Great Ziegfeld

Audience Reviews

View More

Anakin S Feb 12, 2019 Without question, the best Hollywood musical ever brought to fruition. Yes, it is too long and needs editing. Like the Godfather, it needs three parts. But this is the first years of the talkies, give them a break. Nothing so wonderful could be conceived today, and look at all that was saved for posterity. This is the first movie deserving six stars on a five star system. People should view this in three parts and judge it on its incredible opulence, while at the same time still giving us an interesting and compelling plot (unlike today's attempts at musical comedies). This one has it all -- except for slick production value that comes first in today's world. How could you give all this any less than five stars? So much delight, so much talent. See more

Feb 1, 2019 The best musical movie ever made! With the best movie song ever sung: A Pretty Girl Is Like a Melody!

Ron Jan 20, 2018 ***OVERTIRING (179 MINS) YET WORTH A PEEK AT THE FINEST THINGS EVER DONE ON STAGE***

Draco M Nov 29, 2017 As this film clocks in at three full hours, one reviewer likened it to a "huge, lumbering, Paleozoic beast with a heart", and it's a great analogy. It's a chronicle of the career of showman and theater producer Florenz Ziegfeld, Jr, and the highlights are the musical numbers and showy costumes by Adrian in the middle third of the movie which are truly over-the-top. They're also apparently true to the extravagance of his Ziegfeld Follies, which ran on Broadway from 1907 to 1931. The number ""A Pretty Girl Is Like a Melody" is particularly stunning, with the camera going up a lavish, revolving spiral staircase adorned with beautiful men and women, dancers, and performances of classical music along the way. Google it and be suitably impressed for eight minutes. I also liked seeing the tap dance routine from Ray Bolger (the scarecrow from 'The Wizard of Oz'), featuring a few splits that would undoubtedly be quite painful to the average man. Of the cast, William Powell delivers a nice performance in the title role, capturing both the taste and generosity of Ziegfeld, and his relationship with his rival (played by Frank Morgan) is touching. The two of them imbue this biography with class, and through sheer force of will in the production, one can see why the film won the Academy Award for Best Picture. I have to say though, it had too much detail, and for me the first and third hours were too long. Myrna Loy doesn't even make her appearance as Billie Burke until the 2:10 point or so, and her part is rather modest. Luise Rainer plays his first wife, the performer Anna Held, and turns in a mediocre performance, so it's harder to understand her Oscar. Lastly, the film lacks an edge. Ziegfeld was a notorious womanizer, and while that's alluded to, it's all pretty innocent, lacking a certain zest, authenticity, or both. Emotions in general are all muted and glossed over, making us aware of the movie being a theatrical production of its own. You can certainly do worse, but I would only recommend the film with reservations. See more

Finn G Aug 27, 2017 William Powell shines.

Rey W Aug 17, 2017 There are some really gorgeous scenes in this film, especially in the middle. In fact, there is a good hour long movie stuck in the middle of this one, but the beginning and end are very drawn out and boring. Ziegfeld shows what kind of large successes and constant failures can surround someone who risks everything all the time. Though this movie won Best Picture and Actress, with Rainer handing in a great performance, it was a very hard film to get through and I was glad when it finally ended. See more

Read all reviews

The Great Ziegfeld

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING