Mary Elizabeth Williams
Salon.com
Aug 25, 2026
Despite its painfully pat finale, the film does strike a bittersweet chord in anyone still clinging to the part of themselves that once dressed funny and scoffed at the idea of ever fitting in.
Go to Full Review
Amy Taubin
Village Voice
Aug 25, 2026
...James Merendino’s SLC Punk! strikes a brighter chord than the immortal Sid and Nancy, and although fresh and endearing are hardly words you associate with punk, the film doesn’t feel like a cop-out until the very end.
Go to Full Review
Andrea C. Basora
Newsweek
Aug 25, 2026
We don't really need some young punk to tell us that anarchy is an untenable idea, but watching him live it is an invigorating experience.
Go to Full Review
Wesley Morris
San Francisco Examiner
Aug 25, 2026
It's handsome filmmaking that doesn't surface until the final 25 minutes during which Stevo and company's sense of marginalization achieves the palpable, emotional import that's more expressive than anything its characters' have to b**** about.
Go to Full Review
Dennis Harvey
Variety
Aug 25, 2026
...the ironic lameness of an “anarchistic” philosophy being articulated by rich-kid brat bound for law school, so “SLC Punk” itself doesn’t quite grasp how its slick, flashy package undermines any actual punk cred.
Go to Full Review
Lisa Alspector
Chicago Reader
Aug 25, 2026
...freezes interrupt the action to permit [Stevo] to comment on it by directly addressing the camera—part of a hearty style of self-referential filmmaking that only adds to the persuasiveness of Lillard's stunning performance.
Go to Full Review
Peter Bradshaw
Guardian
Aug 25, 2026
For punkology students only.
Go to Full Review
Jeff Simon
Buffalo News
Aug 25, 2026
4/5
Merendino tells his story wildly a la "Trainspotting" - with sudden flashbacks and, in one case, a kind of hilarious mini-essay on fighting as the preferred punk pastime. It is by turns very funny, unsettlingly violent, touching and, ultimately, very sad.
Go to Full Review
Henry Sheehan
Orange County Register
Aug 25, 2026
C+
The result is a bit scattershot, but amusing and touching nonetheless.
Go to Full Review
Jami Bernard
New York Daily News
Aug 25, 2026
3/4
[Salt Lake City]...is where writer-director James Merendino, a man with an eye for the ludicrous, has set his surprisingly genial and affecting comedy about the trials and tribulations of teenage rebellion during the Reagan of '80s.
Go to Full Review
Amanda Schurr
Sarasota Herald-Tribune
Aug 20, 2026
2.5/4
For a stereotypical portrait of angst and aggression, there's certain poseur charm to "SLC Punk." And refreshingly, coffee bars and bad poetry are nowhere to be found.
Go to Full Review
Shawn Levy
Oregonian
Aug 20, 2026
2/4
Like his characters, Merendino is excessively sold on the hipness of his enterprise. But the content of his film is never as potent as its trappings might lead you to believe.
Go to Full Review
Larry Ratliff
San Antonio Express-News
Aug 19, 2026
2/4
Merendino can't quite harness his passion for rebellion into a package of consistent interest.
Go to Full Review
Peter Stack
San Francisco Chronicle
Aug 19, 2026
"SLC Punk!" is all about the fuss and bother of alienated youth. It has a moment of tragedy that is affecting, but it strangely winds up as a noisy trip to that big nowhere of normalcy, hardly the place where punks really want to reside.
Go to Full Review
Steven Rea
Philadelphia Inquirer
Aug 19, 2026
2.5/4
Rambling, episodic and evidently somewhat autobiographical, writer/director James Merendino's film has plenty of raw energy going for it. But SLC Punk also displays a kind of earnest nostalgia that's at odds with the angry-young-man posturing.
Go to Full Review
Rita Kempley
Washington Post
Aug 19, 2026
Typically, movies about misguided punks are so scabrous and their characters so repellent that it's hard to look at them as anything but freak shows. But Stevo and Bob are appealingly puppyish underneath all that bravura.
Go to Full Review
Jack Garner
Rochester Democrat and Chronicle
Aug 19, 2026
7/10
Spiked hair, mid-80's punk music, mosh pits, bad drugs and baseball-bat beatings give SLC Punk its visceral energy. But viewers also will discover surprising insight and even a tiny bit of warm sentiment.
Go to Full Review
Maureen Ryan
Chicago Tribune
Aug 19, 2026
2.5/4
The episodic plot resembles the musical movement it depicts in its homemade earnestness and ragged, jagged feel. Some sequences, however...just don't work and almost stop the film cold.
Go to Full Review
Matt Soergel
Florida Times-Union
Aug 19, 2026
3/4
How much you will like it will depend on how much of the manic Matthew Lillard you can stand, as SLC Punk! is basically all Lillard, all the time.
Go to Full Review
Hazel-Dawn Dumpert
L.A. Weekly
Aug 19, 2026
Written and directed by James Merendino, SLC Punk! is ultimately a wiser and truer film than its crass and cartoony beginnings would have us believe...
Go to Full Review