Brian Eggert
Deep Focus Review
Sep 4, 2023
1.5/4
A dreary, groan-inducing comedy that fails to be funny or entertaining under even the most lenient terms.
Go to Full Review
Mike Massie
Gone With The Twins
Nov 29, 2020
5/10
It may go slightly beyond the blueprints for a formulaic parody movie, but it has all the same symptoms.
Go to Full Review
Richard Propes
TheIndependentCritic.com
Aug 31, 2020
1.0/4.0
Year One relies almost solely upon bawdy, sophomoric humor.
Go to Full Review
Nikki Baughan
Roll Credits
Oct 30, 2019
1/5
Year One buckles at the first bad gag and it's downhill from there.
Go to Full Review
Micheal Compton
Bowling Green Daily News
May 16, 2019
D
Unfortunately, all the talent doesn't translate on the screen. Sure, there are a few mildly amusing moments (most coming courtesy of Cera), but for the most part Year One was one big dud.
Go to Full Review
Megan Basham
WORLD
Mar 3, 2019
Considering Year One is likely to flop, there's little point in giving it the benefit of controversy by protesting too much.
Go to Full Review
Deborah Ross
The Spectator
Aug 29, 2018
All in all, this is a sloppy, unoriginal, brain-dead mess that can't even be bothered to get itself out of trouble.
Go to Full Review
Simon Miraudo
Quickflix
Oct 21, 2014
3/5
In the beginning there was light, which was closely followed by the fart joke.
Go to Full Review
Ali Gray
TheShiznit.co.uk
Sep 29, 2012
2/5
Stretched painfully thin to feature length, it's a concept that's gestated for 34 years but hasn't evolved a microbe. It also proves that the Harold Ramis of '09 has nothing on the Harold Ramis of '75.
Go to Full Review
Joshua Rothkopf
Time Out
Nov 17, 2011
3/5
Go to Full Review
Joshua Starnes
ComingSoon.net
Dec 28, 2010
4/10
Dudley Moore once made a pretty forgettable comedy giving various well-worn bible stories a light irony wash by reacting to them with the skepticism and confusion a person of today might. Year One is basically that, but dumber.
Go to Full Review
Simon Foster
sbs.com.au
Aug 9, 2010
From its ill-concieved concept to its timing-free chemistry and embarrassingly-bad characterisations, Year One is a major misfire in every respect.
Go to Full Review
Andrea Chase
Killer Movie Reviews
Jul 4, 2010
1/5
a lazy excrescence of a film. Crude, sloppy, flat, and singularly uninspired, its only redeeming virtue is proving that Michael Cera is capable of rising above even this abominable material
Go to Full Review
Sam Bathe
Fan The Fire
Apr 15, 2010
2/5
Only big fans of Cera and Black need catch this film, and even then, it's far from a must-see.
Go to Full Review
Marc Savlov
Austin Chronicle
Jan 5, 2010
1/5
What's even more depressing than the never-ending stream of sub-sixth-grade toilet humor is the sad fact that Year One is helmed and co-produced by two of the best laughmeisters in the business.
Go to Full Review
Tom Meek
Boston Phoenix
Jan 5, 2010
1/4
Not everything Judd Apatow touches is gold.
Go to Full Review
J. R. Jones
Chicago Reader
Jan 5, 2010
Creatively it's a giant step backwards, with Jack Black and Michael Cera playing to the kids as inept hunter-gatherers who stumble across various Old Testament characters.
Go to Full Review
Rubin Safaya
Cinemalogue
Dec 6, 2009
D+
The problem is not the historicity, or lack thereof, in a comedy, but the uneven pace of the humor.
Go to Full Review
Nick Rogers
Midwest Film Journal
Dec 3, 2009
.5/4
Producer Judd Apatow has gone from comedy gourmand to McDonald-izing in four years. And when in doubt, director Harold Ramis makes Jack Black eat his own feces and Michael Cera pee in his own mouth. Yes, this is at the level of YouTube monkey comedy.
Go to Full Review
James Plath
Movie Metropolis
Oct 10, 2009
5/10
This one is destined to take its place alongside films like Evan Almighty and Wholly Moses!.
Go to Full Review