Michael Clark Epoch Times Jan 19, 2024 4/5

“Win Win” was Mr. McCarthy’s third effort as a filmmaker and his third straight triumph. Not quite as great as “The Station Agent,” but better than “The Visitor,” it is an art-house drama posing as a mainstream uplifting comedy.

Go to Full Review

Richard Propes TheIndependentCritic.com Sep 27, 2020 3.5/4.0

It contains enough heart and humor to please virtually anyone.

Go to Full Review

Felicia Feaster Charleston City Paper Jan 17, 2020

There is a shambling, lo-fi sweetness to Win Win.

Go to Full Review

Brian D. Johnson Maclean's Magazine Aug 19, 2019

While all this may sound a bit contrived, we're won over by the depth of the characters and fine detail of their world.

Go to Full Review

Kelly Jane Torrance Washington Examiner Jan 8, 2019 3/5

[Amy] Ryan continues to be one of our best supporting actresses, one who shines but doesn't need to steal scenes.

Go to Full Review

Deborah Ross The Spectator Aug 31, 2018

Win Win is a comedy-drama that is warm-hearted and compassionate and enjoyable without, alas, being especially remarkable or original, which is a bit of a blow but I think you'll get over it.

Go to Full Review

Kiko Martinez San Antonio Current Jan 29, 2018 B+

Win Win may not be a flawless victory, but McCarthy is able to pin us down effortlessly nonetheless, proving there's more to life than being carried off the field a hero.

Go to Full Review

Roe McDermott Hot Press Mar 11, 2016

Aided by a fantastic cast, featuring the hilarious Bobby Canavale and the wonderfully strong Amy Ryan, McCarthy's film is overflowing with humour, warmth and pathos. Broad but perfectly constructed, it's a win-win situation.

Go to Full Review

Stephen Rebello Playboy Online Aug 5, 2015

In a still young movie year, Win Win is already on the mat as one of the best.

Go to Full Review

Sean Burns Philadelphia Weekly May 3, 2015

Tom McCarthy doesn't make great movies, but he makes movies about people I enjoy spending time with.

Go to Full Review

Chase Whale Gordon and the Whale Aug 28, 2013

WIN WIN makes Tom McCarthy three-for-three. Grabbing the affection from the audience is what he wants, and dear reader, he can't lose.

Go to Full Review

Scott Foundas Film Comment Magazine Jun 20, 2013

McCarthy understands the thrill of incontrovertible victory and our primal lust for it.

Go to Full Review

Amy Curtis We Got This Covered Jun 2, 2013 7/10

A thoughtful study of relationships and family dynamics, Win Win wrestles the competition to the ground.

Go to Full Review

Jeff Beck Examiner.com Sep 20, 2012 3.5/4

"Win Win" continues McCarthy's streak of bringing realistic characters and realistic situations to life on the screen. He has clearly shown his talent for writing and directing, making him one of those directors to watch out for.

Go to Full Review

Gabe Leibowitz Film and Felt Jan 13, 2012 65/100

There's a real earnestness to the proceedings: if someone had relayed the setup to me via email or over cocktails, I would have bet heavily that we'd be looking at a sappy mess of clichs.

Go to Full Review

Fr. Chris Carpenter Movie Dearest Dec 30, 2011 A-

One of the ten best films of 2011.

Go to Full Review

James Plath Movie Metropolis Dec 29, 2011 8/10

Win Win is worth a look look. As indie dramedies go, it's a good one.

Go to Full Review

Tim Brayton Antagony & Ecstasy Dec 23, 2011 7/10

Excellent performances of good characters in a story that's not as rich as it apparently believes itself to be.

Go to Full Review

Matthew Sorrento Film International Dec 11, 2011 10/10

In Tom McCarthy's Win Win sports may seem to be the means for drama. But when considering the importance of wrestling to the characters, the sport shapes character and narrative.

Go to Full Review

Robert Roten Laramie Movie Scope Dec 3, 2011 B

This combination comedy and drama works well, in part because of good performances by everyone.

Go to Full Review