Rotten Tomatoes
Suggestions will appear as you start typing. Submit search Movies Tv shows RT App New News Showtimes

The Three Musketeers: Part I - D'Artagnan Reviews

All Critics Top Critics All Audience Verified Audience
Hannah Brown Jerusalem Post Apr 17, 2025
The movie is enjoyable, filled with swashbuckling and banter, and concentrates on presenting the 1600s with realistic grit and filth, and on the intrigues of the palace and the clergy in all their double-crossing detail.
Go to Full Review
Francesca Steele iNews.co.uk Dec 11, 2024 5/5
This star-studded bromance is just the sort of swashbuckling silliness we need.
Go to Full Review
John Serba Decider Nov 20, 2024
... A movie that’s otherwise a mostly well-made, rousing adventure that’s probably worth a look.
Go to Full Review
James Croot The Post NZ Aug 11, 2024 4/5
Forget the mixed-bag of Hollywood’s ‘70s, ‘90s and 2011 takes on Alexandre Dumas’ tale, this is the real crowd-pleasing deal. Boasting lashings of action, political scheming and romance, this gripping adventure will have you hooked from the first frames.
Go to Full Review
John McDonald Australian Financial Review Jun 18, 2024
Although he virtually invented the potboiler, Dumas’s books have a panache that distinguishes them from those lifeless popular squibs written to a formula.
Go to Full Review
Cris Kennedy Inner East Review May 30, 2024 4/5
The casting is inspired, especially when it comes to the Musketeers.
Go to Full Review
Andiee Paviour Nobody's Reading This But Me May 18, 2024 3.5/5
The umpteenth adaptation of an 180-year-old classic is rife with machismo writ large.
Go to Full Review
Leigh Paatsch Herald Sun (Australia) May 17, 2024 4.5/5
The dynamically dashing nature of the action scenes live up to the swashbuckling standards many will be expecting.
Go to Full Review
Jim Schembri jimschembri.com May 17, 2024 3/5
The umpteenth movie adaptation of Alexandre Dumas’s classic 1844 novel gets a good, if stern, going over in a handsomely costumed production.
Go to Full Review
Nadine Whitney The Curb May 17, 2024
Extravagantly expensive, action heavy – the films are exactly what they claim to be – blockbuster cinema.
Go to Full Review
Stephen Romei The Australian May 10, 2024 3.5/5
This film is gorgeously shot by cinematographer Nicolas Bolduc. It opens with a take-no-prisoners fight in the rain and mud that includes D’Artagnan and Milady and sets the scene for all that is to follow.
Go to Full Review
Michael Talbot-Haynes Film Threat Feb 1, 2024 9.5/10
It almost resembles a spaghetti western over how authentically all the ornate 17th-century finery is encrusted with filth. Compared to recent blockbuster attempts, an unmistakable edge is achieved here.
Go to Full Review
Frank Swietek One Guy's Opinion Dec 13, 2023 B
Though one can question some of the filmmakers’ decisions, generally they pull off the attempt to revivify Dumas’ flavorful swashbuckler for modern audiences.
Go to Full Review
Alan Zilberman Spectrum Culture Dec 12, 2023 4/5
It is romantic in the classic sense of the word. These characters have values, and although the film is frequently funny, it never sneers at honor or chivalry. When Athos announces he would rather die than betray his King, we believe him.
Go to Full Review
Amyana Bartley QBP Reviews Dec 12, 2023
D’Artagnan proves itself a highly worthy contestant amongst its predecessors, shining with exemplary visual craft, writing and acting.
Go to Full Review
Robert Abele Los Angeles Times Dec 11, 2023
What this installment energetically proves is that you can ruffle the feathers of a totemic tale and still capture what’s good, galloping fun in Dumas’ storytelling.
Go to Full Review
Daniel M. Kimmel North Shore Movies Dec 10, 2023 4/5
THE THREE MUSKETEERS: D’ARTAGNAN tells the first half of the story, and is the first from France in decades, filled with sword fights and palace intrigue, but never losing sight of the characters amidst all of the swashbuckling.
Go to Full Review
Peter Debruge Variety Dec 9, 2023
Dumas was a master of the serial form, and this version of “The Three Musketeers” manages to preserve that thrill-to-thrill sensation.
Go to Full Review
Todd Jorgenson Cinemalogue Dec 8, 2023
Slick and stylish, this latest cinematic adaptation of the venerable adventure saga hardly breaks any new ground, but it showcases a strong cast and some exciting action sequences.
Go to Full Review
Christopher Llewellyn Reed Hammer to Nail Dec 8, 2023
It helps that the cast is excellent, the production design exquisite, and the camera appropriately frenetic. These musketeers have panache, and I am all here for it.
Go to Full Review
Load More
Join The Newsletter Join The Newsletter Cookie Settings