David Hogan
hoganreviews.co.uk
Nov 12, 2026
2/5
A flat film. It redoes a lot of the original movie like it’s a remake despite being a prequel and the CG effects are just not very good and made even worse if you watch the original 80s Thing before or after it.
Go to Full Review
Eddie Harrison
film-authority.com
Apr 5, 2026
3/5
The Thing 2011 has a strong, moody atmosphere, some wild jump scares, some decent tension, and does feel like a loving tribute to the original film. It’s one case where it would be interesting to see a director’s cut...
Go to Full Review
Patrick Cavanaugh
The Wolfman Cometh
Sep 9, 2025
2/5
Not only were audiences confused over whether this was a prequel or a reboot, but the film itself also didn't seem to know whether it wanted to do its own thing or just recycle tried-and-true sequences that made Carpenter's film so original.
Go to Full Review
Matt Brunson
Film Frenzy
Apr 27, 2023
2/4
It’s actually a prequel to the 1982 movie, leading one to wonder why they didn’t more accurately name it The Thing: The Beginning, The Thing: The Early Days or even I Was a Teenage Thing.
Go to Full Review
Brian Eggert
Deep Focus Review
Mar 7, 2023
2/4
Van Heijningen’s new film can’t decide if it wants to elaborate on Carpenter’s version or pay homage to it, and that indecision is where the fault lies.
Go to Full Review
Keith Garlington
Keith & the Movies
Aug 25, 2022
3/5
This prequel to John Carpenter’s 1982 horror classic manages to capture enough of the shocks and paranoia of its predecessor to be successful.
Go to Full Review
Owen Nicholls
NME (New Musical Express)
May 6, 2021
Sitting in negative digits on the movie-o-meter-as-temperature-scale...
Go to Full Review
Mike Massie
Gone With The Twins
Nov 30, 2020
5/10
The changes to the creature, the revealing of its natural state, and the expansion of its mythology detract from the overall terror.
Go to Full Review
Richard Propes
TheIndependentCritic.com
Sep 26, 2020
1.5/4.0
The actors aren't brilliant here, but much of the film's deficits can be placed squarely upon the shoulders of its first-time helmer.
Go to Full Review
Brent McKnight
The Last Thing I See
Jul 11, 2020
C
Just average, which is sad, really, because there are quite a few missed opportunities in the script that, while they wouldn't have made for a great film, could have made it a fun B-style sci-fi horror movie. I
Go to Full Review
Ed Travis
Cinapse
Nov 13, 2019
I've come to outright enjoy [The Thing] as a love letter to [John] Carpenter's film and a thrilling companion piece to that unblemished masterpiece.
Go to Full Review
Leslie Combemale
Cinema Siren
Jul 29, 2019
This paranoid frozen frightfest is the best chance to you'll get this Halloween to feel a real chill.
Go to Full Review
Ellie Lucas
The Dispatch (Lexington, NC)
Jun 8, 2019
2/4
I doubt that it will enjoy the same positive re-evaluation later on down the road that its predecessor enjoyed and will quickly fade into obscurity while Carpenter's endures.
Go to Full Review
Abbie Bernstein
Assignment X
Feb 8, 2019
B-
Ultimately, the 2011 The Thing is an acceptable creature feature, but it's unlikely to be anybody's favorite thing, let alone considered the best possible Thing.
Go to Full Review
Daniel Green
CineVue
Dec 6, 2018
1/5
Not only a pale imitation of the previous two incarnations, but also one of the worst films (horror or otherwise) released this year -- avoid at all costs.
Go to Full Review
Jessica Baxter
Film Threat
Aug 9, 2017
Watching The Thing, I was absolutely stunned by its complete and utter lack of creativity.
Go to Full Review
David Nusair
Reel Film Reviews
Aug 11, 2013
1/4
A misguided and generally worthless prequel...
Go to Full Review
Will Leitch
Deadspin
Jun 23, 2013
C-
There's just no sense of dread in this "Thing," no notion that these people are truly at the edge of the world, with nowhere to escape and no one to trust.
Go to Full Review
Steve Newton
Georgia Straight
Feb 15, 2013
1.5/5
Since Heijningen already had dibs on The Thing's hallowed name, he didn't even bother trying to conjure any of its slow-burning suspense or claustrophobic vibe.
Go to Full Review
Kristal Cooper
We Got This Covered
Sep 22, 2012
5/10
The fact that The Thing falls flat is proof positive that unlike the film's industrious alien, parasitic remakes can't easily carbon copy the host.
Go to Full Review