Matt Oakes
Silver Screen Riot
Oct 15, 2026
C-
Climbing fanatics and family members of lost hikers will probably enjoy this film regardless of its faults, since it is packed with detail, but the rest of us will be left cold.
Go to Full Review
Allen Almachar
The MacGuffin
Jul 23, 2020
B
It's a cautionary tale, where the slightest mistake could have tremendous consequences.
Go to Full Review
Bernard Boo
Way Too Indie
Apr 11, 2019
6.7/10
The constant bombardment of facts, opinions, and time jumps is a lot to digest, causing a lot of the emotional bits to slip through the cracks.
Go to Full Review
Dan Schindel
Nonfics (Substack)
May 30, 2014
1/5
Structurally confused and suspect in its depiction of the events. Bad taste and poor decisions waylay any attempt at emotion.
Go to Full Review
Donald Clarke
Irish Times
Nov 27, 2013
3/5
Visually impressive and well-researched, The Summit certainly stirs up the terror and mystery that attended that disastrous weekend.
Go to Full Review
Michael Sragow
Orange County Register
Oct 30, 2013
A-
Remarkably, The Summit achieves some of the same dizzying impact as Gravity -- by philosophical and psychological means, rather than special effects.
Go to Full Review
Katherine Monk
Canada.com
Oct 25, 2013
3/5
The Summit rises above the foothills of clich to bring some existential oomph to the accident scene.
Go to Full Review
Radheyan Simonpillai
NOW Toronto
Oct 25, 2013
2/5
The Summit picked up an editing prize at Sundance, which you can only surmise was awarded because the film does a fine job of leaving you as confused as the people on K2.
Go to Full Review
Linda Barnard
Toronto Star
Oct 24, 2013
2.5/4
The subject is fascinating and the cinematic punch afforded by peaks so massive, inspiring with their terrible beauty is a filmmaker's dream.
Go to Full Review
Marc Savlov
Austin Chronicle
Oct 18, 2013
2/5
It still works as a cautionary tale of man vs. nature hubris, but the endgame finger-pointing among survivors, their families, and one amazing Nepalese sherpa leaves the viewer frustrated.
Go to Full Review
Tom Long
Detroit News
Oct 18, 2013
C
You have a tangled story being told by director Nick Ryan and writer Mark Monroe in a somewhat tangled way. The result isn't as much confusing as it is distracting.
Go to Full Review
Tom Russo
Boston Globe
Oct 17, 2013
2/4
First-time director Nick Ryan isn't entirely up to the challenge in "The Summit," but he does deliver some dramatic and visual highs in the attempt.
Go to Full Review
Kelly Vance
East Bay Express
Oct 11, 2013
The seriousness of the climbers' predicaments overshadows practically every quibble with the story.
Go to Full Review
Rich Cline
Shadows on the Wall
Oct 11, 2013
3/5
This strikingly well-made documentary about a harrowing real-life incident lets itself down by taking a too-ambitious approach to the narrative.
Go to Full Review
Steven Rea
Philadelphia Inquirer
Oct 11, 2013
2.5/4
At once repetitive and puzzling. There is a lot of finger-pointing. Assertions are made, theories offered, but not much in the way of certainty.
Go to Full Review
Mathew DeKinder
Suburban Journals of St. Louis
Oct 11, 2013
3.5/5
'The Summit' is at its best when it tries to get to the bottom of what went wrong up on that mountain, which leads to exploring what sent these people up there in the first place.
Go to Full Review
Ben Sachs
Chicago Reader
Oct 10, 2013
There's something unsettling about a real-life tragedy presented as an action film; that the filmmakers never acknowledge this is more unsettling yet.
Go to Full Review
Michael O'Sullivan
Washington Post
Oct 10, 2013
2.5/4
It's frustrating not to know exactly what occurred when, how and to whom. Of course, some of this is due to the fact that nobody really knows everything that happened, except, as someone notes, the mountain itself.
Go to Full Review
Joe Williams
St. Louis Post-Dispatch
Oct 10, 2013
3/4
"The Summit" is an impressive achievement, but there's a good reason to ask whether cameras are turning the planet into a playground for the reckless rich: because it's there.
Go to Full Review
Randy Cordova
Arizona Republic
Oct 10, 2013
2/5
A film that feels curiously hollow.
Go to Full Review