Keva York
The Saturday Paper
Jul 16, 2026
The Mastermind is a characteristically ultra-dry genre piece from Kelly Reichardt, whose lightness of touch tends to belie her films’ sharp impact.
Go to Full Review
Matt Brunson
Film Frenzy
Jul 5, 2026
3/4
A low-key gem.
Go to Full Review
Jeff Beck
The Blu Spot
Jul 1, 2026
2.5/5
The Mastermind has a fair amount of potential as it sets up its intriguing heist tale..., but it sadly loses its way rather quickly as it becomes quite clear that Reichardt simply didn't know where to take the story after that.
Go to Full Review
Andrew Kendall
Stabroek News
Jun 21, 2026
Reichardt lucks out on a performer whose natural energy insists that we pay him our attention even when the film itself might give us few reasons to invest in him. He is an endlessly watchable performer, and "The Mastermind" exploits that
Go to Full Review
Rich Cline
Shadows on the Wall
Mar 27, 2026
4/5
Everything is remarkably understated, often playing out in silence, which adds both humour and tension as events continually spiral in unexpected directions.
Go to Full Review
Will DiGravio
Cineaste Magazine
Mar 6, 2026
Reichardt tells this 110-minute story with a pace bordering on slow cinema ... and it is spectacular.
Go to Full Review
Brett McCracken
The Gospel Coalition
Feb 6, 2026
Everything in The Mastermind—including its sepia palette and slow, long-take pace—is meant to convey the malaise and stagnation of the 1970s in contrast to the flower-power idealism of the 1960s.
Go to Full Review
Chris Akiba
Mediaversity Reviews
Feb 1, 2026
C
The Mastermind stands out for its character-driven narrative and immersiveness, but stereotypes are allowed to play out without interrogation.
Go to Full Review
Filipe Freitas
Always Good Movies
Jan 27, 2026
4/5
Simmering without boiling, The Mastermind peels off the surfaces of old-school heist genre, smartly avoiding commonplace, complacency, and demagogy to achieve something truly moody and dusky.
Go to Full Review
Jeffrey M. Anderson
Common Sense Media
Jan 22, 2026
4/5
Kelly Reichardt's ironically titled ninth feature is a shaggy, bad-luck crime story that deliberately and brilliantly sucks anything thrilling or glamorous out of the life of an art thief.
Go to Full Review
JD Duran
InSession Film
Jan 7, 2026
A+
The Mastermind is straight out of the New Hollywood era. It's almost as if it time-traveled from the 1970s into 2025.
Go to Full Review
David Walsh
World Socialist Web Site
Jan 6, 2026
2/4
Is such a "subversion" of this type of misogyny truly important, or, frankly, even necessary? Don’t we have bigger fish to fry? The end result of this misplaced concern with the secondary and even tertiary is a rather drab and even dull film.
Go to Full Review
Michael Calleri
Niagara Gazette
Jan 4, 2026
Josh O’Connor’s performance is exceptional and the production values are outstanding in "The Mastermind," a very good art heist movie. The mechanics of the planning and actual theft are delivered with an accomplished, albeit cleverly distanced, style.
Go to Full Review
Mitchell Beaupre
The Film Stage
Jan 1, 2026
Kelly Reichardt’s ’70s Robert Altman picture: A hangdog tale of a man who simply cannot get out of his own way.
Go to Full Review
Ruth Maramis
FlixChatter Film Blog
Dec 22, 2025
2.5/5
The idea of an unconventional, minimalist heist film is intriguing, but this one tests my patience quite a bit, even with the immensely watchable O’Connor on screen for most of it.
Go to Full Review
Santanu Das
Hindustan Times
Dec 20, 2025
3.5/5
The Mastermind is a political film in the realist, most gripping manner, which intends to knock its protagonist- and in extension, the viewer- sideways.
Go to Full Review
Chuck Bowen
Style Weekly (Richmond, VA)
Dec 20, 2025
Quietness paired with the right actors allow us to feel as if we are seeing the process of thought in motion.
Go to Full Review
Grant Watson
Fiction Machine
Dec 20, 2025
7/10
It is less calm than it is relaxed; indeed it seems almost laconic in both literal and visual language. It is not a film one watches so much as soaks in.
Go to Full Review
Michael J. Casey
Metro Arts
Dec 20, 2025
4/5
A final shot that gives you everything you want out of this narrative.
Go to Full Review
Aaron Neuwirth
We Live Entertainment
Dec 19, 2025
7/10
Even if it were just a lark, the enjoyable performances and jazzy score by Rob Mazurek do plenty to satisfy the audience.
Go to Full Review