Richard Freedman
Newark Star-Ledger
Jan 12, 2026
A haunting, richly rewarding recreation of one of the towering masterpieces of English fiction.
Go to Full Review
Lorien Haynes
Radio Times
Nov 11, 2025
4/5
Not as good as the novel, but still has much to recommend it, not least the evocative Oscar-winning photography.
Go to Full Review
Judith Martin
Washington Post
Jun 17, 2022
This is cinematography at its best -- film used to present a view, in motion, of a reality that has been artistically ordered to reveal a greater-that-literal essence.
Go to Full Review
Gary Arnold
Washington Post
Jun 17, 2022
Watching this long, placid maddeningly subdued movie, you can't help wondering what became of Hardy's stark chronicle of crimes of passion.
Go to Full Review
Scott Sublett
Washington Blade
Jun 17, 2022
It does not shout and it does not speed; it rolls along effortlessly, at an even rate, like a country brook, and when it ends one wishes for more.
Go to Full Review
Richard Schickel
TIME Magazine
Jun 17, 2022
One emerges from [Roman Polanski's] endless version of Thomas Hardy's Tess of the D'Urbervilles with a sense that one could have read the book in a shorter span and had more fun too.
Go to Full Review
Jasper Rees
The Arts Desk
Jun 17, 2022
5/5
The triumph of Tess is in the yoking of remorseless Hardian sadism to the natural photogenic allure of both Kinski and her surroundings (not to mention Anthony Powell’s gorgeous costumes).
Go to Full Review
Richard Roud
Guardian
Jun 17, 2022
The film has all the air of an expensive, classy commercial product, the result more of market research than intimate inspiration... [Roman Polanski's] experiences seem to have left [him] without much compassion, and Tess without compassion is nothing.
Go to Full Review
Stephen Schiff
Boston Phoenix
Jun 17, 2022
It's not art at all. It's art-like. Tess feeds on a sort of romanticized self-pity. If indeed Polanski sees himself mirrored in Tess's story, it's not as the resilient, sensual, quietly outraged character that Hardy imagined, but as a victim.
Go to Full Review
Michael Maza
Arizona Republic
Jun 17, 2022
Tess is a beautiful film -- three hours (including an intermission) of perfectly lit, mood-evoking shots on locations that make us feel as if we've traveled through time as well as space on this tour of the English countryside.
Go to Full Review
Patrick Taggart
Austin American-Statesman
Jun 17, 2022
Tess is Roman Polanski's Barry Lyndon. Much like Stanley Kubrick's film of five years ago, Tess is a spacious, atmospheric and brilliantly photographed period piece based on a novel about a hapless pawn of a highly regimented British caste system.
Go to Full Review
R.H. Gardner
Baltimore Sun
Jun 17, 2022
This fidelity to the original [novel], combined with the director's efforts to approximate in visual terms the author's prose, gives the film a quality of authenticity and power that lifts it far above the ordinary.
Go to Full Review
Bruce McCabe
Boston Globe
Jun 17, 2022
This film is one of those rare treasures that restores one's faith in the efficacy of the cinema.
Go to Full Review
Catherine Chapin
Charlotte Observer
Jun 17, 2022
Tess is sinfully delicious melodrama, but there's a somber undercurrent of snobbery, pettiness and the rigid Victorian notion that peasants were property, not people.
Go to Full Review
Roger Ebert
Chicago Sun-Times
Jun 17, 2022
4/4
It is a beautifully visualized period piece that surrounds Tess with the attitudes of her time -- attitudes that explain how restricted her behavior must be, and how society views her genuine human emotions as inappropriate. This is a wonderful film.
Go to Full Review
Gene Siskel
Chicago Tribune
Jun 17, 2022
3/4
Polanski's Tess is the rarest of contemporary movies, an old-fashioned kind of romantic drama that commercial Hollywood hasn't made in years.
Go to Full Review
CSM Staff
Christian Science Monitor
Jun 17, 2022
Mr. Polanski's version seems rather stolid, though he sticks firmly to Hardy's moving tale of a lass whose love life carries her to a tragic fate. Yet it's sensitively directed, in its own conservative way, and luminously photographed.
Go to Full Review
Patrick Gibbs
Daily Telegraph (UK)
Jun 17, 2022
How strange that a Polish director working on locations in France should make one of the most faithful and satisfying film versions of a classic English novel in my memory.
Go to Full Review
Jack Mathews
Detroit Free Press
Jun 17, 2022
Though its approximate three-hour run (intermission included) may seem to pass more slowly than an evening with the book itself, it is a soothing spectacle.
Go to Full Review
Bernard Drew
Gannett News Service
Jun 17, 2022
A beautifully wrought, handsomely produced, flawlessly directed and acted film. It's as faithful to its source as any film version of a novel I've ever seen, and in addition, is possessed of an exquisite, incandescent performance by Nastassja Kinski.
Go to Full Review