Lee Tuohy
Sunday Independent (Ireland)
Jul 29, 2026
Cusack's extrovert antics might have been cushioned but for his inept co-star who pouted her way throughout. A pit, it could have been a very funny film.
Go to Full Review
Michael Walsh
The Province (Vancouver)
Jul 29, 2026
Warm as well as funny, The Sure Thing is a cheerful, unexpected love story.
Go to Full Review
Marsha Fottler
Sarasota Herald-Tribune
Jul 29, 2026
"The Sure Thing" is a road romance-comedy made special by the fresh faces, the young talent and some first-rate writing.
Go to Full Review
David Wilson
Tulsa World
Jul 29, 2026
2.5/4
It's fun, but it could have been fantastic.
Go to Full Review
James Calloway
News & Observer (Raleigh, NC)
Jul 29, 2026
2.5/4
The end product is a lightweight comedy that doesn't leave a lasting impression.
Go to Full Review
John Kiely
Waterloo Region Record
Jul 29, 2026
It is not uncommon for directors to suffer a sophomore jinx after an initial success, the terrible thing about Reiner's face-forward flop is that he has chosen to fail with such a mediocre, such a mundane movie.
Go to Full Review
Bob Lundegaard
Minneapolis Star Tribune
Jul 29, 2026
It isn't a bad movie exactly, but if you called it a laugh riot, a good lawyer would have you at his mercy.
Go to Full Review
John Laycock
Windsor Star
Jul 29, 2026
Amazing -- here's a quiet college comedy. And warm, too. Intelligent. Even understanding. Which makes it even funnier.
Go to Full Review
Mike Studley
Liverpool Echo
Jul 29, 2026
Warm and witty.
Go to Full Review
Morley Walker
Winnipeg Sun
Jul 29, 2026
Too bad a filmmaker as promising as Reiner must succumb to recycling tired ideas.
Go to Full Review
John Dodd
Edmonton Journal
Jul 29, 2026
3.5/4
What's remarkable is Reiner's restraint and good taste.
Go to Full Review
Bill Brownstein
Montreal Gazette
Jul 29, 2026
No great surprise as to who eventually beds down with whom, but the charm of the players and audacity of their director make it all worthwhile.
Go to Full Review
Fred Haeseker
Calgary Herald
Jul 29, 2026
The bones of the formula occasionally stick out, but the film is kept afloat by Reiner's sense of comic timing and the ability of the characters to keep surprising us.
Go to Full Review
Lou Cedrone
Baltimore Sun
Jan 21, 2026
"The Sure Thing" is a delight throughout.
Go to Full Review
Charlie Patton
Florida Times-Union
Jan 21, 2026
3/4
It's funny, romantic and extremely well-acted.
Go to Full Review
Matt Brunson
Film Frenzy
Jan 14, 2026
3/4
In a decade largely defined by raunchy teen sex comedies, here's a film that stood out from the pack thanks to its sweetness and sincerity.
Go to Full Review
Steve Simels
Video Review
Jan 8, 2026
Because director Reiner coaxes believable and accomplished performances out of his costars, The Sure Thing registers as one of the funniest and best observed coming-of-age movies in memory.
Go to Full Review
Michael D. Reid
Victoria Times Colonist (B.C., Canada)
Jan 8, 2026
4/5
Light, witty and engaging, Rob Reiner's new comedy about a pair of star-crossed teenagers is a pleasure to behold, a giddy, refreshing departure from the mindlessness prevalent in most modern youth-oriented capers.
Go to Full Review
Jack Mathews
USA Today
Jan 8, 2026
3/4
Cusack and Zuniga do remarkable jobs of turning two routine characters into believable, well-rounded teens.
Go to Full Review
Rob Salem
Toronto Star
Jan 8, 2026
It's often very wordy, especially Cusack's speeches, but even when there's too much of it, the dialogue is sharp and funny.
Go to Full Review