Rotten Tomatoes
Suggestions will appear as you start typing. Submit search Movies Tv shows RT App New News Showtimes

Stranger on the Third Floor

Play trailer Poster for Stranger on the Third Floor 1940,  1h 4m,  Crime/ Drama Play Trailer Watchlist
Stream Now Watchlist 75% 28 Reviews Tomatometer 64% 500+ Ratings Popcornmeter
75% Tomatometer 28 Reviews 64% Popcornmeter 500+ Ratings
When upstart journalist Michael Ward (John McGuire) testifies that he saw Joe Briggs (Elisha Cook Jr.) at the scene of a murder, Briggs is jailed and sentenced to death. Later, Michael's conscience and troubling dreams get the better of him. He tells his girlfriend, Jane (Margaret Tallichet), that he isn't certain Briggs is guilty. They begin to investigate, but unfortunately, the couple soon makes the acquaintance of an ominous, enigmatic man (Peter Lorre) who wants the case to stay closed.
Watch on Fandango Stream Now

Where to Watch

Stranger on the Third Floor

Stream

Rent Stranger on the Third Floor on Fandango, or buy it on Fandango.

Stranger on the Third Floor

What to Know

Critics Consensus

While it suffers from the occasional stilted performance, Stranger on the Third Floor turns its gripping premise into a visually persuasive noir nightmare through bold production design and Boris Ingster's striking direction.

Read Critics Reviews

Critics Reviews

View More
SMH Staff Sydney Morning Herald Feb 10, 2026
There is nothing routine here, and the acting by some comparative strangers is another proof that it does not need leading players to make a good story arresting. The romance of the narrative also has some fresh treatment. Go to Full Review
Guardian Staff Guardian Feb 10, 2026
"Stranger on the Third Floor" is another example of the unpretentious pot-boiler achieving the dignity and design of an epic. Go to Full Review
Philip K. Scheuer Los Angeles Times Feb 10, 2026
The production rates as a novelty and should exert a spell above that of the routine program effort. With it, Boris Ingster accomplishes a promising directorial debut. Go to Full Review
Matt Brunson Film Frenzy Mar 12, 2026
3/4
The very first film noir? Good luck finding a definitive answer. Yet in recent times, the frontrunner for that title would seem to be Stranger on the Third Floor. Go to Full Review
Photoplay Staff Photoplay Feb 10, 2026
Staging is dramatic and suspense well sustained. Go to Full Review
Miami Herald Staff Miami Herald Feb 10, 2026
The picture... is designed to raise goose pimples and chill your spine, though it isn't hard to figure out to the end that suspense is lacking. Go to Full Review
Read all reviews

Audience Reviews

View More
Leia P Jan 4, 2019 Not a great movie by normal standards, but deserves a ratings bump for the place it has in noir history. The elements that earn it the distinction of being considered the first noir are definitely there and a pleasure to watch. Peter Lorre is the other highlight of the flick, to be sure. All in all, an enjoyable and worthy watch. See more
Draco G Dec 1, 2018 Acting a little hokey, but well done for its time period.
Finn M Jun 30, 2018 Decent murder turned suspense caper where McGuire is a reporter who is the witness against an alleged murderer. Yet, as can be predicted, it may not have been and of course there is another murder and a more nefarious suspect - Lorre. Very pedestrian with an extend dream sequence. Resolves itself in the usual pat manner. Just ok. See more
Leia S Mar 18, 2018 Not quite perfect, but it still has its unique elements that put it above others. The dream sequence is one of those. Lorre's teeth were something too! See more
Han G Mar 11, 2018 Character actors Cook Jr, Halton, & our hero McGuire really fill out this film admirably. Tallichet also seems to hit her marks and deliver charming nuances for her role. The cinematography & editing certainly seem to deliver a product the close to what any director should be happy with. While this is sometimes touted as the first Film Noir, I would say this is a progenitor of the genre. The streets are dim echoes of fritz Lang's M (which also starred Lorre) in which an all night search miraculously uncovers a psychotic - who doesn't scream "Hilfe!" in this film. And a few scenes show a strong influence of German Expressionist cinema - not quite the archetypal American Noir yet. While Lorre does an excellent job once more, it's a shame he took so long to break out of this stereotype. A shame he was ever locked into a stereotype as Lorre was a great character actor who could do everything... except dance. See more
Abraham W Feb 7, 2018 Is this the first film noir? Some think so -- but of course, the genre has no real beginning nor end and was never more than a loose association defined by the common elements. Certainly, many of the elements are here, including low key (high contrast) lighting, voice-over narration, a horrifying dream sequence, a man or two poked by the fickle finger of fate, and the presence of Elisha Cook, Jr. and Peter Lorre (both of whom also appeared in another film also identified as a harbinger of the genre, The Maltese Falcon, 1941). Here, Lorre is given top billing (as a result of his starring role in the Mr Moto series), but he has only a few scenes as the titular stranger who ultimately becomes a suspect for the two murders that reporter Mike Ward (played by John McGuire) gets entangled with. But there is quite a lot of action before we ever meet Lorre: Ward is the star witness at a murder trial but he and his girlfriend come to have doubts about whether the poor shmuck who was convicted (yes, Elisha Cook, Jr.) really did it. The style (by cinematographer Nicolas Musuraca) is influenced by the German Expressionist movement (though not to the level of Caligari) and Ward seems genuinely haunted (bring on the dream sequence). But it is all over and done with in about an hour and the ending is unexpectedly upbeat. The best noirs were yet to come! See more
Read all reviews
Stranger on the Third Floor

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING
Never Love a Stranger 36% Never Love a Stranger Watchlist Kid Glove Killer 83% 56% Kid Glove Killer Watchlist Desperate 100% 66% Desperate Watchlist Eleni 83% 75% Eleni Watchlist My Gun Is Quick 28% My Gun Is Quick Watchlist Discover more movies and TV shows. View More

Movie Info

Synopsis When upstart journalist Michael Ward (John McGuire) testifies that he saw Joe Briggs (Elisha Cook Jr.) at the scene of a murder, Briggs is jailed and sentenced to death. Later, Michael's conscience and troubling dreams get the better of him. He tells his girlfriend, Jane (Margaret Tallichet), that he isn't certain Briggs is guilty. They begin to investigate, but unfortunately, the couple soon makes the acquaintance of an ominous, enigmatic man (Peter Lorre) who wants the case to stay closed.
Director
Boris Ingster
Producer
Lee S. Marcus
Production Co
RKO Radio Pictures Inc.
Genre
Crime, Drama
Original Language
English
Release Date (Theaters)
Aug 16, 1940, Limited
Release Date (Streaming)
Jan 1, 2012
Runtime
1h 4m
Join The Newsletter Join The Newsletter Cookie Settings