Alan Jones
Radio Times
Nov 5, 2025
2/5
Superficially faithful to the original film's subtle horror, this sloppy sequel diffuses what one character calls "the aesthetic observance of violence" into the safely ludicrous and lifeless.
Go to Full Review
Keith Garlington
Keith & the Movies
Aug 25, 2022
1.5/5
...a profound mess of a movie.
Go to Full Review
Brian Eggert
Deep Focus Review
May 29, 2022
1.5/4
Overall, this is D-level material, and the only genuine shock it delivers is that it didn’t debut on VOD or Netflix.
Go to Full Review
Richard Crouse
Richard Crouse
Feb 3, 2021
1/5
Not scary enough to be called a horror film, it isn't funny enough, intentionally anyway, to be a comedy.
Go to Full Review
Debbie Lynn Elias
Behind The Lens
Dec 8, 2019
3/5
One of the weaker sequels in the Blumhouse arsenal in terms of terror and suspense, Sinister 2 is nevertheless solid filmmaking with high production values, interesting script and character development
Go to Full Review
Justin White
Cultured Vultures
Oct 9, 2019
The movie does what it says. Sinister 2 is all about the feeling that something evil, menacing, and disturbing will happen; that's what it literally leaves you hoping for.
Go to Full Review
Joey Keogh
Wicked Horror
Sep 26, 2019
4/10
Not nearly special, or even scary, enough to justify its existence, it neither furthers Bagul's back-story nor does anything new with the character.
Go to Full Review
Ellie Lucas
The Dispatch (Lexington, NC)
Jul 5, 2019
1.5/4
A few chilling images and a terrific score by tomandandy can't make up for lackluster performances (mainly from a completely miscast lead), over-reliance on jump scares and an overall sense of ennui.
Go to Full Review
Abbie Bernstein
Assignment X
Dec 14, 2018
B
Sinister 2 doesn't rise to the level of classic, but it is an effective continuation of the original, spooky enough to rank as a very decent horror outing.
Go to Full Review
Frank Ochieng
SF Crowsnest
Nov 10, 2018
2/4
Sinister II's crime is not so much the calculating presence of a haunt hipster looking to stunt the growth of bewildered housing inhabitants as it is following the pedestrian path of boofests with banal bangs of exhilaration.
Go to Full Review
Molly Henery
The Blogging Banshee
Nov 2, 2018
4.5/10
It had the potential to be as good as the first film, but the filmmakers made unfortunate choices that diluted the main story line and overexposed everything that was supposed to be scary.
Go to Full Review
Aaron Peterson
The Hollywood Outsider
Oct 25, 2018
6.5/10
Sinister 2 is a definite improvement on the first film, enriching the narrative with a heavier emphasis on mood and expanding the universe as a whole.
Go to Full Review
Mark Shrayber
Jezebel
Jun 13, 2018
Sinister 2 is an awful movie.
Go to Full Review
Brooke Corso
The MacGuffin
Aug 1, 2017
D
By the tortured end (for the viewer), we are left with the inquietude of another sequel coming. From the mouth of madness, we know this story won't end.
Go to Full Review
Rebecca Pahle
Pajiba
Sep 21, 2016
No one expects low-budget horror sequels to be the height of innovation. But it's still a shame, because it left a talented director without much to work with.
Go to Full Review
Marija Djurovic
Cairo360
Apr 5, 2016
1/5
If ever there was a perfect example of the misguided nature of the film sequel, Sinister 2 is it. You can commend a sequel for trying to build on and expand the original, but this film seems to have regressed.
Go to Full Review
J.C. Maçek III
PopMatters
Mar 29, 2016
4/10
In a film where ghostly children attempt to force other kids to watch horror movies only to be repeatedly told "I don't' want to", this somehow manages to be a microcosm for Sinister 2. I don't want to watch any more either.
Go to Full Review
Paul Chambers
Movie Chambers
Feb 7, 2016
D+
"Sinister 2" depends greatly on cheap scares.
Go to Full Review
Felix Vasquez Jr.
Cinema Crazed
Jan 27, 2016
A lackluster follow up to what was a fairly unimpressive horror entry.
Go to Full Review
John Noonan
FILMINK (Australia)
Jan 22, 2016
Whilst Sinister 2 at least manages to avoid being a mere re-tread, the final product comes off as decidedly flat.
Go to Full Review