Gary Wolcott
Tri-City Herald
Apr 1, 2025
C+
Black does not have the skill to carry an entire movie... Despite that drawback and the film's one-dimensional plot, Shallow Hal has a terrific message.
Go to Full Review
Philip French
Observer (UK)
Nov 8, 2023
After a ponderous start, the Farrellys eventually unveil their big dramatic idea rather slowly, but don't know where to take it. Having wandered around in circles for nearly two hours they end up in embarrassment.
Go to Full Review
Roger Clarke
Independent (UK)
Nov 8, 2023
2/5
Unexpectedly rather sweet and underplayed, given that it comes from the gross-out kings.
Go to Full Review
Telegraph Staff
Daily Telegraph (UK)
Nov 8, 2023
The situations become too embarrassing to be funny.
Go to Full Review
Mike Massie
Gone With The Twins
Nov 9, 2020
5/10
The pervasive, uncomfortable feeling from Hal's confusion distracts from the commendable nature of the themes and the effectiveness of the humor.
Go to Full Review
Debbie Lynn Elias
Behind The Lens
Nov 16, 2019
Obviously no one bothered to tell Bobby and Peter Farrelly to stick to what they do best in film making - insanity, stupidity and raunchy bathroom jokes.
Go to Full Review
Christy Lemire
Associated Press
Jun 12, 2018
A movie that meanders from one sight gag to the next, many of which you've already seen in the commercials.
Go to Full Review
Nell Minow
Common Sense Media
Dec 28, 2010
3/5
Romantic comedy is pretty tame for Farrelly Bros.
Go to Full Review
Todd McCarthy
Variety
Oct 18, 2008
With the relatively untested Black coming on awfully strong, the lack of directorial finesse lets the enterprise down, creating some clunky scenes and dead air where laughs might have been expected.
Go to Full Review
Emanuel Levy
EmanuelLevy.Com
Jan 13, 2007
C
The Farrellys take an artistic step backward with this soft, disappointingly sentimental comedy about the true nature of beauty; they seem to have forgotten their roots in the outrageous and gross-out.
Go to Full Review
Betsy Bozdech
DVDJournal.com
Nov 9, 2006
3/4
A sweet romantic comedy that rises above its moments of lowest-common-denominator humor ... to offer a positive message about love and perception.
Go to Full Review
Derek Adams
Time Out
Jun 24, 2006
The film is not as funny as their best, but fascinates in the discomforting way it foregrounds the brothers' normally buried, facile moral dialectic.
Go to Full Review
Jeffrey M. Anderson
Combustible Celluloid
May 26, 2006
[An] insulting new comedy from Bobby and Peter Farrelly.
Go to Full Review
Vadim Rizov
Movie-Vault.com
Jun 19, 2003
4/10
Go to Full Review
Tom Grealis
RTÉ (Ireland)
Feb 13, 2003
3/5
There's just about enough charm and laughs here to keep Farrelly fans happy. Even the fat ones.
Go to Full Review
John R. McEwen
Film Quips Online
Feb 8, 2003
3.5/5
Go to Full Review
Jeffrey Chen
Window to the Movies
Jan 12, 2003
7/10
In delivering their message, the Farrelly Brothers seem to have compromised their nothing-is-sacred comedy spirit, but at least their hearts are in the right place.
Go to Full Review
Matthew Turner
ViewLondon
Oct 30, 2002
3/5
Go to Full Review
Mark Palermo
The Coast (Halifax, Nova Scotia)
Oct 14, 2002
When the final act descends into preachiness, it's nearly earned the indulgence.
Go to Full Review
Urban Cinefile Critics
Urban Cinefile
Aug 17, 2002
The key to enjoying Shallow Hal is to discard as many expectations as you can about a Farelly Brothers film.
Go to Full Review