Kim Newman
Sight & Sound
May 13, 2026
Settlers leaves many plot point events off screen to concentrate on the daily struggle, which makes it perhaps too dour for its own good.
Go to Full Review
Michael Cook
Geek Vibes Nation
Jul 17, 2025
3/5
Those who like slow-paced, introspective films are probably going to be quite drawn to this. But those who prefer narratives with clearer motivations, character arcs, and plotlines might find Settlers frustratingly lacking.
Go to Full Review
Rick Bentley
KGET-TV (Bakersfield, CA)
Aug 10, 2023
2/5
This film that looks at life in the frontier of space is painfully frustrating.
Go to Full Review
Dallas King
Flick Feast
Nov 12, 2022
2/5
Settlers leaves far too many questions unanswered. Ultimately making for a frustrating narrative experience.
Go to Full Review
Alex Welch
Inverse
Oct 24, 2022
Wyatt Rockefeller’s slow-burn sci-fi Western will keep you on your toes.
Go to Full Review
Cheryl Eddy
io9.com
Oct 24, 2022
The characters are carefully constructed to support this bleak vision, with the help of excellent performances all around.
Go to Full Review
Lupe Rodriguez Haas
CineMovie.tv
Oct 24, 2022
It's a promising start as a film debut for Rockefeller.
Go to Full Review
Mel Valentin
ScreenAnarchy
Oct 18, 2022
A deeply unsettling, discomfiting exploration of a simple, if still provocative, thesis.
Go to Full Review
Thomas Stoneham-Judge
ForReel Movie News And Reviews
Oct 18, 2022
4/5
Within the 103 minute runtime, Settlers might not be perfect storytelling, but Rockefeller’s first foray into feature length narrative filmmaking delivers on many respectable fronts.
Go to Full Review
M.N. Miller
Ready Steady Cut
Oct 9, 2022
3/5
Settlers can be an almost excessively unpleasant pandemic-inspired allegory, but a remarkably honest one.
Go to Full Review
Keith Garlington
Keith & the Movies
Aug 17, 2022
4/5
As “Settlers” eases from a simmer to a boil the story’s bleakness becomes more evident. It feeds into the film’s idea that no matter where we go, we can never escape the ugly side of human nature.
Go to Full Review
Dan Bayer
Next Best Picture
May 10, 2022
6/10
Ending on a note that leaves the audience wanting more is a good thing, to be sure, but ending on a note that leaves the audience feeling unfulfilled is not, and despite its strong craft, Settlers is firmly in the latter camp.
Go to Full Review
Grant Watson
Fiction Machine
Nov 24, 2021
5/10
It is a watchable film, but it begs for patience - not just for the plot but for its writer/director's inexperience.
Go to Full Review
Richard von Busack
SF Weekly
Aug 13, 2021
It's a film without villains, only deluded or deceptive men, and it ends in a ferocious stalemate that counters the Biblical view of a man's duty to settle and dominate a bleak land.
Go to Full Review
Jeremy Aspinall
Radio Times
Aug 12, 2021
3/5
It's a sombre affair that even a helpful WALL-E-type droid can't lighten, but the mystery is teased out enticingly thanks to ambient mood music from Nitin Sawhney.
Go to Full Review
Carla Hay
Culture Mix
Aug 1, 2021
[It] seems like it was an idea that was originally conceived as a short film, but somehow it got stretched into dull junk that trudges to an unsurprising and lackluster end ... There are plenty of better and more memorable movies about life on Mars.
Go to Full Review
Robert W. Butler
Butler's Cinema Scene
Jul 30, 2021
B-
When it comes to envisioning and creating a tangible world, Setters is terrifically seducive.
Go to Full Review
Larushka Ivan-Zadeh
The Times (UK)
Jul 30, 2021
2/5
There is life on Mars and it's a godawful small affair, according to this determinedly sombre sci-fi film.
Go to Full Review
Paul Mount
Starburst
Jul 30, 2021
2/5
Settlers may well appeal to those who prefer their science fiction a bit more grounded and thoughtful but the film's glacial pace and lack of momentum suck the life out of it.
Go to Full Review
Rob Aldam
Backseat Mafia
Jul 30, 2021
Everything feels derivative and there's no real narrative heft to cling on to.
Go to Full Review