Javier Ocaña
El Pais (Spain)
Apr 30, 2025
Themes such as feminine complexity, the denunciation of suppressed racism, and activism in favor of family diversity emerge in its story, but Labed fails to combine them into a sufficiently seductive, albeit lewd, work. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Eulàlia Iglesias
Fotogramas
Apr 30, 2025
3/5
In her debut film, [Ariane] Labed demonstrates her ability to generate disturbing and suggestive atmospheres...[Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Luis Martínez
El Mundo (Spain)
Apr 30, 2025
3/5
Ariane Labed makes her directorial debut with a surgical and very gothic dissection of puberty that is as vivid and murky as it is ultimately rushed. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Nando Salvá
Cinemanía (Spain)
Apr 29, 2025
3/5
More effective at generating atmosphere than in its narrative role. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Matthew Briody
Film Ireland Magazine
Apr 25, 2025
Employing bold visuals and leaning into close-up, static shots, Labed's direction entices audiences into the strange world of these three complex women.
Go to Full Review
Isabella Silvers
Mashable
Mar 17, 2025
With a sparse script, minimal score and grainy visuals, plus the remote setting of the house in Ireland, which looks like it’s been left untouched for decades, audiences are drawn into the sisters’ insular world.
Go to Full Review
Katie McCabe
Sight & Sound
Mar 10, 2025
Labed’s film, like Johnson’s novel, understands how sisters practise life on one another, testing out the worst facets of their personalities until they are ready to present them to the world.
Go to Full Review
Chris Wasser
Sunday Independent (Ireland)
Feb 26, 2025
2/5
Does it all come together? Not really. Nice performances, though.
Go to Full Review
Grant Rollings
The Sun (UK)
Feb 26, 2025
2/5
I’d say no matter which month it is, very little about this small-budget movie is worth following.
Go to Full Review
Mark Kermode
Kermode and Mayo's Take (YouTube)
Feb 26, 2025
For a good two-thirds of it, I thought it was really decent...
We will see better work from this writer/director in the future because there is a lot of promise.
Go to Full Review
Ellen E Jones
Observer (UK)
Feb 24, 2025
2/5
These directorial choices also act to keep the sisters at an emotional distance, as if the camera were another classmate wary -- or weary? -- of their kooky unpredictability. Would that the plot twist was equally unpredictable.
Go to Full Review
Brian Viner
Daily Mail (UK)
Feb 21, 2025
3/5
It is compellingly unsettling throughout.
Go to Full Review
Kevin Maher
The Times (UK)
Feb 21, 2025
2/5
The closing twist is crudely telegraphed earlier on and arrives with a naff explanatory flashback that’s laugh-out-loud preposterous. So no, not an especially successful adaptation.
Go to Full Review
Jonathan Romney
Financial Times
Feb 20, 2025
2/5
September Says never quite gels. But Tharia and Kann give vivid, unsettling performances, bringing an enthusiastic spark to a film that otherwise seems to float in its own hermetically sealed space.
Go to Full Review
Peter Bradshaw
Guardian
Feb 18, 2025
2/5
A film that feels actorly rather than real.
Go to Full Review
Shannon Cotter
Film Ireland Magazine
Feb 18, 2025
The third act unfolds in a way that lacks foreshadowing, yet Labed’s debut is so haunting and assured—packed with eerie imagery and unsettling performances—that it’s entirely possible we’re witnessing the birth of a future classic.
Go to Full Review
Clotilde Chinnici
Loud and Clear Reviews
Sep 14, 2024
3.5/5
Nonetheless, September Says is a very exciting and fascinating movie, especially as a debut from a filmmaker that I hope we can see much more of in the near future.
Go to Full Review
Nadine Whitney
AWFJ.org
Aug 28, 2024
4/5
A sophisticated, poetic, and thorny story of guilt and repression, September Says is a dark mirror of unrealised and unstable identity. Waking up to reality is unkinder when even the most twisted of fantasies are grounded in unspoken truth.
Go to Full Review
Àngel Quintana
Caimán Cuadernos de Cine
Jul 26, 2024
A film that knows how to create a brilliant atmosphere, but whose result is hampered by her [Labed] attachment to an unexpected plot twist. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Öykü Sofuoğlu
In Review Online
Jun 4, 2024
Films too often value concept over emotion and sterile provocation over sincerity, a mistake Labed savvily avoids to her film’s considerable benefit.
Go to Full Review