Jared Richards
The Age (Australia)
Aug 18, 2026
2/5
A tender, touching film, emotionally distorted by director-writer Carmen Emmi’s non-linear narrative and grainy, VHS footage – a visual representation of surveillance and self-policed repression that obscures more than it adds.
Go to Full Review
Manuel Betancourt
FilmWeek (LAist)
Dec 31, 2025
I really enjoyed the vibes of it all because it's really trying to capture a moment... The sense of surveillance feels integral rather than flashy.
Go to Full Review
Christy Lemire
FilmWeek (LAist)
Dec 31, 2025
There's way too much stuff going on.
Go to Full Review
John Stark
Mac the Movie Guy
Nov 29, 2025
63/100
Plain Clothes is honest, portraying internal turmoil in relatable fashion. the only dressing down here is the lack of audio description, which would have turned it into a complete outfit.
Go to Full Review
Alex Heeney
Seventh Row
Nov 25, 2025
It’s a part of recent history ripe for revisiting, especially as audiences will have more compassion for these men than they have for themselves.
Go to Full Review
Olivia Popp
Purple Hour
Nov 18, 2025
Plainclothes emerges as an impressive feature debut precisely because of how it incorporates style and content; one without the other would render the film a much more average drama.
Go to Full Review
Joe Lipsett
The Queer Gaze (Podcast)
Oct 30, 2025
3/5
The use of video is overdone to the point of distraction but Blyth and Tovey's committed performances help to smooth over most of the rough edges. This is a throwback to a rough time for queers (the 90s), though the ending is overwrought and too dramatic
Go to Full Review
Tom Dawson
Radio Times
Oct 29, 2025
3/5
There are convincing performances here from both Blyth and Tovey, even if the film stumbles in its final act, relying on a melodramatic confrontation for its conclusion.
Go to Full Review
Stephen A. Russell
ScreenHub
Oct 29, 2025
A tantalisingly slow-burn 90s-set drama ... The audience is held claustrophobically tight as the cat-and-mouse game plays out.
Go to Full Review
Amelia Harvey
Movies We Texted About
Oct 24, 2025
Plainclothes is a film which works on different levels. It’s a sexy psychodrama about hidden love affairs and inner shame, but it’s also a much-needed reminder of recent queer history.
Go to Full Review
Beth Webb
Empire Magazine
Oct 22, 2025
4/5
Carmen Emmi compellingly mines thriller tropes to capture the fraught experience of suppressed sexuality, but it's Lucas and Andrew’s heart-rending, beautifully performed love story that endures.
Go to Full Review
Marlon Wallace
The M Report (WBOC.com)
Oct 15, 2025
...establishes early that this film is really about the mental health of his protagonist... the film looks like Academy ratio on a 35 mm print... It's box-like, almost as if to box us into the head and the mind of the main character.
Go to Full Review
Alexander Mooney
Little White Lies
Oct 14, 2025
2/5
Plainclothes is especially frustrating because its frenetic presentation and sensational scenario initially suggest a coherent perspective – hard to come by in the increasingly censored and commodified landscape of queer cinema.
Go to Full Review
Jack Martin
Film Feeder
Oct 13, 2025
3.5/5
A strong psychodrama that is occasionally undone by its conventional nature and emotional coldness but still manages to deliver one hell of a payoff.
Go to Full Review
Mark Kermode
Kermode and Mayo's Take (YouTube)
Oct 11, 2025
Once again, independent low-budget cinema made by people who really care turns out to be the most interesting thing on release.
Go to Full Review
Alex Davidson
Sight & Sound
Oct 10, 2025
Tovey gives a smartly understated performance, Andrew’s calmness simultaneously bringing a stability lacking in Lucas’s life while suggesting an enigmatic, unknowable edge to his character.
Go to Full Review
Jared Mobarak
Hey, Have You Seen ...?
Oct 10, 2025
9/10
It’s a fantastic turn by Blyth as he treads through the innocence and pleasures of desire while existing in a walled-off prison of prejudice pretending to be morality.
Go to Full Review
Juan Barquin
MovieWeb
Oct 8, 2025
2.5/5
Carmen Emmi has made a perfectly watchable debut feature, but it's a shame that it wastes the overwhelming potential of its premise.
Go to Full Review
Peter Bradshaw
Guardian
Oct 6, 2025
2/5
Plainclothes is heartfelt in many ways, but burdened with a colossally melodramatic ending.
Go to Full Review
Rubén Rosario
MiamiArtZine
Oct 6, 2025
The performances are so strong, the stars' chemistry so beguiling, they almost overcome the shortcomings that hold “Plainclothes” back. What ultimately does the movie in is a misbegotten framing device...
Go to Full Review