Rotten Tomatoes
Suggestions will appear as you start typing. Submit search Movies Tv shows RT App New News Showtimes

Phantom Lady Reviews

All Critics Top Critics All Audience Verified Audience
Matt Brunson Film Frenzy Mar 12, 2026 3/4
The first half of this striking film noir is phenomenal, but it’s not too difficult to figure out the killer even before he’s revealed at the film’s halfway point.
Go to Full Review
Jay Carmody Washington Star Mar 6, 2026
Apart from its relative humorlessness, Phantom Lady is enough like a Hitchcock picture to justify your seeing it if you think you would like to see human misconduct exacting its inevitable and logical price.
Go to Full Review
Jack Karr Toronto Star Mar 6, 2026
[Harrison] knows, in fact, all the tricks to bring an audience's blood pressure to the boiling point of excitement.
Go to Full Review
Ernest Dudley Sunday Mirror (UK) Mar 6, 2026 6/10
It's a whodunit mystery melange, which definitely had me guessing—guessing as to what the film was all about.
Go to Full Review
SMH Staff Sydney Morning Herald Mar 6, 2026
Phantom Lady has more obvious affectations in style than the earlier film [Shadow of a Doubt], but maintains its suspense more evenly and more relentlessly so that there is scarcely a minute lost in which an audience can unclench its teeth.
Go to Full Review
Jack Balch St. Louis Post-Dispatch Mar 6, 2026
Miss Harrison's done very well in her first start.
Go to Full Review
Hortense Morton (Screen Scout) San Francisco Examiner Mar 6, 2026
The suspected husband role is smoothly played by Alan Curtis, and Ella Raines is lovely and sympathy-inspiring in her part.
Go to Full Review
SF Chronicle Staff San Francisco Chronicle Mar 6, 2026
Joan Harrison, the producer, has become famous overnight in Hollywood for the making of Phantom Lady.
Go to Full Review
Harold V. Cohen Pittsburgh Post-Gazette Mar 6, 2026
Phantom Lady may not be pure Hitchcock, but it's a crisp imitation, a moody, flinty mystery bathed in soupy suspense.
Go to Full Review
C.A. Lejeune Observer (UK) Mar 6, 2026
American murder mystery, which sometimes seems to have ideas above its station. The acting, though, restores the balance.
Go to Full Review
Kate Cameron New York Daily News Mar 6, 2026
The director has profited by Alfred Hitchcock's method of establishing a suspenseful mood at the beginning of the picture and sustaining it throughout the development of the screen story.
Go to Full Review
Gazette Staff Montreal Gazette Mar 6, 2026
Mood is assured by virtue of the fact that all of the action, except for one brief street scene and a courtroom sequence, takes place at night. That the mysterious killer is a psychopathic intellectual also helps.
Go to Full Review
Robert E. Murphy Minneapolis Star Tribune Mar 6, 2026
This is a very well-done mystery yarn, altering the proceedings by having the real criminal known to the audience through most of its length.
Go to Full Review
Philip K. Scheuer Los Angeles Times Mar 6, 2026
A remarkable achievement...
Go to Full Review
Mary Hunt London Evening Standard Mar 6, 2026
Ella Raines has been creeping up in stardom for some time. In this picture she reaches her goal.
Go to Full Review
KC Star Staff Kansas City Star Mar 6, 2026
Phantom Lady may be tedious at times, but it comes off with some share of entertainment.
Go to Full Review
Houston Chronicle Staff Houston Chronicle Mar 6, 2026
It is a suspense-filled, well-directed, and exciting murder mystery.
Go to Full Review
Courant Staff Hartford Courant Mar 6, 2026
Phantom Lady is psychological drama at its best. It has atmosphere. It has an intensity that is held throughout. It has a fine cast. In short, you'll want to see it.
Go to Full Review
Roly Young Globe and Mail Mar 6, 2026
Ella Raines does an excellent job as the sleuthing secretary.
Go to Full Review
Ida Belle Hicks Fort Worth Star-Telegram/DFW.com Mar 6, 2026
It's well woven and well executed, and except for a few spots, it's believable.
Go to Full Review
Load More
Join The Newsletter Join The Newsletter Cookie Settings