Kim Newman
Sight & Sound
May 14, 2026
Old is at least as much black comedy as horror.
Go to Full Review
David Day
Horror Movie Talk
Sep 23, 2025
7/10
I found myself giddy with laughter at points in Old, and oddly disturbed at other points. Mostly I had a wonderful time in the theater giggling like a school-girl with my buddy Bryce, tittering over little jokes we made or quotes we thought of.
Go to Full Review
Geoffrey Macnab
iNews.co.uk
Jan 16, 2025
3/5
It is fun throughout, though, and the director manages to hint at some deeper themes even as he throws in his familiar fairground flourishes.
Go to Full Review
Rick Bentley
KGET-TV (Bakersfield, CA)
Aug 10, 2023
0.5/5
Shyamalan’s efforts to stretch this into 108 minutes leaves far too many dull lapses.
Go to Full Review
Zach Pope
Zach Pope Reviews
Jul 26, 2023
A HORRIFYING Concept that will have you leaving the theater contemplating your life & the time you spend in it!
Go to Full Review
Manuel SĂŁo Bento
MSB Reviews (Ghost.io)
Jul 25, 2023
C-
Old is one of those cases of a remarkably unique, intriguing concept failing to reach its potential due to an overall disappointing execution of too many ideas.
Go to Full Review
Emma-Jane Betts
The Digital Fix
Jul 25, 2023
3/5
Questionable conclusions aside, you still can’t deny the beautiful simplicity of Old’s concept or the cast’s stellar performances throughout the feature.
Go to Full Review
Akos Peterbencze
Vulnerable Man (Medium)
Jul 24, 2023
...Old fails to live up to its potential because of its half-baked, poorly written characters
Go to Full Review
Bill Bria
Vague Visages
Jun 6, 2023
That pitch and pace unfortunately does the ensemble cast no favors, all of them struggling mightily to deliver some of the clunkiest dialogue of Shyamalan’s career.
Go to Full Review
Brett Doze
InSession Film
May 2, 2023
B-
Though Old has a number of observable shortcomings, my overall impression of the film that sticks with me is that of excitement and amusement.
Go to Full Review
Elissa Suh
Moviepudding (Substack)
Mar 13, 2023
Shymalan’s latest is compellingly perverse and wracked with a real sense of menace, making its hopeful denouement something of a betrayal.
Go to Full Review
Matt Pais
MattPais.com
Oct 12, 2022
C
Quite beautiful and very stupid.
Go to Full Review
Keith Garlington
Keith & the Movies
Aug 17, 2022
3.5/4
“Old” sees Shyamalan once again blending the supernatural with the real world to make something that’s uniquely his own. Not everyone will be onboard, but I was.
Go to Full Review
Prahlad Srihari
Firstpost
Aug 8, 2022
2.5/5
Add Old to the unrealised potential column of M Night Shyamalan's filmography.
Go to Full Review
David Gonzalez
The Cinematic Reel
Jun 10, 2022
2.5/4
The director’s latest reconfirms my original sentiments that M. Night Shyamalan is a one-trick pony who isn’t the most exciting filmmaker.
Go to Full Review
Daniel Howat
Next Best Picture
May 20, 2022
5/10
"Old" is wildly inconsistent, preventing it from ever being genuinely as good as some of the director's better works such as "The Sixth Sense," "Unbreakable," or "Split."
Go to Full Review
Amy West
Digital Spy
Apr 26, 2022
2/5
Old's breakneck pacing once things start going south leaves little room to delve into character and personal relationships, or feature enough quieter flashes that would have helped to create sympathy for these people we've not long met.
Go to Full Review
Grant Watson
Fiction Machine
Mar 13, 2022
8/10
iOldi represents the sort of solid mid-range thriller that use to litter the multiplexes 25 years ago.
Go to Full Review
Britany Murphy
Screen Queens
Feb 26, 2022
Try as it might, Old doesnt live up to its trailer, nor does it stand tall against some of Shyamalans other films.
Go to Full Review
Carson Timar
Clapper
Feb 22, 2022
What is clear, however, is that Old is nowhere near the project many were hoping it would be and will leave many audience members and long-time Shyamalan fans shaking their heads.
Go to Full Review