Rotten Tomatoes
Suggestions will appear as you start typing. Submit search Movies Tv shows RT App New News Showtimes

Offseason Reviews

All Critics Top Critics All Audience Verified Audience
Anya Couture Geek Vibes Nation Jul 26, 2025 5/10
It’s now unfortunately trapped in its own thematic stasis, never able to break above the problems it’s created, almost exactly like its island’s doomed residents.
Go to Full Review
Bee Delores B-Sides & Badlands Jul 9, 2024 5/5
Keating stages an enthralling ghost story about human deterioration, inherited trauma, and grief.
Go to Full Review
Paul LĂŞ Nightmare on Film Street Jul 23, 2023 8/10
Offseason is ultimately more about mood than action. Viewers will no doubt feel the strain of Keating’s deliberate pacing and the frustration of his answering questions with even more questions.
Go to Full Review
Jason Shawhan Nashville Scene Jul 14, 2022
The vibe is very Messiah of Evil with some Fulci feels mixed in, and it’s resonant in unexpected ways. It also gets at the very specific kinds of obstinacy that come from Floridian menace and the way the populace responds to it.
Go to Full Review
Joel Fisher Battle Royale With Cheese Jul 5, 2022
Offseason may put audiences off if they can guess the ending in the first ten minutes, but at least it looks good enough so that you can focus on the visuals.
Go to Full Review
Jennie Kermode Eye for Film Jun 22, 2022 3/5
Keating is a master of building up atmosphere and is much more interested in that than in conventional plot mechanics.
Go to Full Review
Jon Mendelsohn CBR Jun 18, 2022
Offseason has thrilling potential, but the predictable storylines deliver a lackluster haunt despite the good cast and cinematography.
Go to Full Review
Murjani Rawls Substream Magazine Jun 11, 2022
'Offseason' is exceptionally confident in the tone it wants to set, but not as much in the story that it desires to tell.
Go to Full Review
Raquel Stecher Quelle Movies Jun 6, 2022
Offseason offers some fun summertime spooks especially for those who love demonic/paranormal horror.
Go to Full Review
Ned Booth The Playlist Apr 16, 2022 C-
As much as this seaside folk horror tale suffers from Keatings usual foibles, like too many inter-titles and an inert script, theres nonetheless something chilling about its premise.
Go to Full Review
Wade Major FilmWeek (LAist) Mar 30, 2022
I've seen everything that inspired the DNA of this horror film. It's just doing it with less, and not very impressively.
Go to Full Review
Amy Nicholson FilmWeek (LAist) Mar 30, 2022
A small and occasionally strong thriller. It reminds me of an extended Twilight Zone episode.
Go to Full Review
Emma Wolfe SpookyAstronauts Mar 25, 2022 6/10
It's films like this that disappoint me the most, not because they're awful, but because they had so much potential, so much going for them, and they fall short.
Go to Full Review
Walter Chaw Film Freak Central Mar 23, 2022 1.5/4
What I'm trying to say is that Offseason introduces a lot of ideas it doesn't land. It does, however, feature a great turn by Donahue, who deserves another film like The House of the Devil. I hope she gets one.
Go to Full Review
Joel Copling Spectrum Culture Mar 20, 2022
Atmosphere gets one only so far with a movie, and unfortunately it doesnt get us very far with this one.
Go to Full Review
Dennis Harvey 48 Hills Mar 15, 2022
The setup is fine, but not enough happens to build sufficient steam before our spooky ride is abruptly over.
Go to Full Review
Joe Friar Fort Worth Report Mar 13, 2022 3/4
Keating's latest horror outing is ripe with tension, brimming with disturbing visuals, and features another solid performance by Jocelin Donahue.
Go to Full Review
Oscar Goff Boston Hassle Mar 11, 2022
It's a genuinely scary piece of work, well-acted and -directed, which takes a relatively simple idea and knocks it out of the park.
Go to Full Review
Mark Dujsik Mark Reviews Movies Mar 11, 2022 1/4
Writerdirector Mickey Keating's Offseason is an exercise in shallow, overly familiar atmosphere and very, very little else.
Go to Full Review
Frank Swietek One Guy's Opinion Mar 11, 2022 C
The short running-time makes a visit to Keatings latest tolerable, but its not a vacation spot you need seek out.
Go to Full Review
Load More
Join The Newsletter Join The Newsletter Cookie Settings