Terrence O'Brien
The Verge
May 19, 2026
It’s a remarkably efficient film that barely gives you a chance to breathe.
Go to Full Review
John Stark
Mac the Movie Guy
May 17, 2026
85/100
What’s inn the box. If I was in the movie, I would have Kool-Aid Man’d my way out of the house. Do not pass Go, keep your $200. The fact this thing stays out as long as it does is why people always die in horror movies. Sell the house. Move far far away.
Go to Full Review
Adam Nayman
Sight & Sound
Dec 18, 2025
The jump scares, when they inevitably come, are handled just the right ratio of shamelessness to skill.
Go to Full Review
Bryce Hanson
Horror Movie Talk
Dec 4, 2025
10/10
...for some reason, instead of rolling my eyes, I was truly engaged with this movie. I think it’s because all of the reality-based elements seem plausible, and all the supernatural elements seem interesting or novel.
Go to Full Review
Cameron Ritter
Geek Vibes Nation
Jul 20, 2025
8/10
Nearly every shot in Oddity is unnerving.
Go to Full Review
Joonatan Itkonen
Region Free
Jul 15, 2025
4/5
By understating the fantastical elements of his world, McCarthy opens the door for uncertainty and doubt, which gnaws at us until the devastating and quietly horrifying final scene, where his work finally pays off.
Go to Full Review
Julian Singleton
Cinapse
Jul 11, 2025
While McCarthy’s sophomore feature is first and foremost a horror film, the cast’s performances give Oddity an intriguingly chameleonic tone, allowing the audience room to constantly question just what genre the film might truly belong to.
Go to Full Review
John Serba
Decider
Apr 7, 2025
Oddity is a ghost story, a whodunnit, a jump-scare freakout, a twisty slow-burn psychothriller and a revenge saga all wrapped into one taut little horror film.
Go to Full Review
Joe Lipsett
Horror Queers Podcast
Mar 5, 2025
4.5/5
From its intricately plotted screenplay to Carolyn Bracken's impeccable lead performance (not to mention some of the most patient, yet effective, scares we've seen in quite some time), Oddity is a real winner.
Go to Full Review
Trace Thurman
Horror Queers Podcast
Mar 4, 2025
4/5
Damian McCarthy's follow-up to his already solid debut film Caveat is confident, assured and (most importantly) scary.
Go to Full Review
Lalo Ortega
Cine Premiere
Feb 18, 2025
3.5/5
[A] gothic horror where danger comes from unexpected places, although it is perhaps too restrained for its own good. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Rebecca Sayce
Starburst
Jan 23, 2025
4/5
With an almost unbearable sense of dread, Oddity is a triumphant comeback for Mc Carthy, who has cemented his status as a filmmaker destined to make great and ghoulish things.
Go to Full Review
Maitland McDonagh
MaitlandOnMovies (Substack)
Jan 20, 2025
It eschews jump scares in favor of a more subtle — and harder to pull off — gradual escalation of unease and accretion of unnerving details
Go to Full Review
David Nusair
Reel Film Reviews
Jan 15, 2025
3/4
Oddity has been suffused with a handful of genuinely creepy (and shocking) images and moments that prove effective at sustaining one’s interest throughout...
Go to Full Review
Diego Batlle
Otroscines.com
Jan 15, 2025
3.5/5
...McCarthy almost never loses his course and demonstrates in several scenes a precise timing that is rare in someone who is only on his second feature. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Phil Hoad
Guardian
Dec 31, 2024
4/5
This carefully controlled and pointedly shot film takes a hoary old set of staples and cobbles together something admirably original.
Go to Full Review
Grant Watson
Fiction Machine
Dec 23, 2024
6/10
When the film is good it can be exceptional, showing off strong technique and inventive ideas. For the most part, however, it is hobbled by more than its fair share of creative problems – not to mention a key ethical one.
Go to Full Review
Brian Bisesi
Horror Movie Club Podcast
Dec 18, 2024
4/5
Oddity infuses originality into the classic gothic horror structure, but it shines the brightest in its masterfully crafted home invasion scenes, which contain some of the most suspenseful movie moments of the year.
Go to Full Review
Keri O'Shea
Warped Perspective
Dec 15, 2024
Oddity turns out to be a pleasing, lean, mean supernatural horror which makes all of its artefacts and ideas count, and you find yourself rooting for all of its moments of bloody comeuppance.
Go to Full Review
Sebastian Zavala Kahn
Ventana Indiscreta
Dec 13, 2024
4/5
Oddity is an intriguing horror film that plays with the viewer's expectations, alternating between supernatural and realistic problems. Although it doesn't offer much tension at first, its ending is horrifying enough. Full review in Spanish.
Go to Full Review