Will Bjarnar
Geek Vibes Nation
Jul 19, 2025
3.5/10
If the contents of Nutcrackers aren’t outright stolen from other, arguably better works, they are certainly hand-me-downs that don’t fit. A refund would be appreciated.
Go to Full Review
Louisa Moore
Screen Zealots
Jan 4, 2025
There is nothing redeeming about this half-hearted drivel. This is absolute garbage that fails to live up to even the lowest of low expectations.
Go to Full Review
James Croot
The Post NZ
Jan 1, 2025
A delightful, fairly anarchic comedy in the spirit of under-rated ‘80s tales Uncle Buck or Mr. Mom.
Go to Full Review
Keith Garlington
Keith & the Movies
Dec 26, 2024
2/5
You can sense what the movie is shooting for and you can imagine ways that it might have worked. But the lack of originality, the overreliance on a tired formula, and the uninspired humor keeps the movie from ever earning our investment.
Go to Full Review
Calum Baker
Radio Times
Dec 21, 2024
3/5
David Gordon Green directs with a measured touch that allows the gang's relationship to evolve with some naturalism.
Go to Full Review
Dustin Rowles
Pajiba
Dec 19, 2024
It’s sweet, a little unusual, and there’s just enough of an indie film vibe to understand why Stiller and Cardellini signed on.
Go to Full Review
Scott Howard
Under the Radar
Dec 13, 2024
6.5/10
There’s a surprising amount of heart in this holiday release featuring Ben Stiller and director David Gordon Green.
Go to Full Review
Stephen Silver
The SS Ben Hecht
Dec 12, 2024
Not much funny happens here, and the film doesn't even remember to put Stiller in put-upon suitor mode, which is what he's best at.
Go to Full Review
Jesse Hassenger
AV Club
Dec 12, 2024
B
What Green adds to familiar material is a sense of genuine wildness—and, at times, eerie ritual. He recognizes something tribal about the raising of close siblings, and their near-feral nature adds jolts of humor and, eventually, heartbreak.
Go to Full Review
Alissa Wilkinson
New York Times
Dec 9, 2024
It’s not really a family film, at least not for many families — the home-school lesson tells you why — but it’s not really a grown-up comedy either. It hovers in an uncanny valley, and the tonal swing is unpleasant.
Go to Full Review
Jennifer Green
Common Sense Media
Dec 9, 2024
It takes a while, but this family dramedy with endearing characters finds its rhythm midway through the story and builds to a fairly predictable but enormously gratifying ending.
Go to Full Review
Rachel Wagner
Hallmarkies Podcast
Dec 7, 2024
A sweet and endearing family holiday comedy
Go to Full Review
Alison Gillmor
Winnipeg Free Press
Dec 6, 2024
3.5/5
Nutcrackers might sound formulaic, but it feels a bit indie, thanks to a loose, lo-fi, purposely aimless narrative and some oddball direction by David Gordon Green.
Go to Full Review
Ayeen Forootan
In Review Online
Dec 6, 2024
Despite failing to ever truly impress either in its comedic gags or bids at zaniness, Nutcrackers does tickle a nostalgic pleasure center when it is at its best, giving viewers a lightly entertaining bit of holiday viewing.
Go to Full Review
Aaron Neuwirth
We Live Entertainment
Dec 6, 2024
6/10
We get what feels more like a slice-of-life drama that’s only slightly heightened at times for some humor.
Go to Full Review
Chris Joyce
Movies and Munchies (YouTube)
Dec 5, 2024
3.5/5
While the story itself isn’t unique, the charm of the characters mixed with the relatable humor and touching conversations make for an enjoyable holiday watch.
Go to Full Review
John Serba
Decider
Dec 4, 2024
Nutcrackers finds plenty of heartwarming comedy that emerges from the characters and their interactions, and is noticeably free of try-hard stabs at big, broad laughs.
Go to Full Review
Matt Zoller Seitz
RogerEbert.com
Dec 2, 2024
3/4
Stiller has become a deeper actor with age, and he's perfect here: you know he has a good soul, because this is a comedy, and not a dark one, but he keeps you guessing.
Go to Full Review
Bill Newcott
The Saturday Evening Post
Dec 1, 2024
3/5
Director David Gordon Green, known mostly for his horror movie sequels, seems an odd choice to helm a heartfelt holiday movie, but his instinctive edginess ably navigates the sentiment-versus-mayhem tightrope walk created by writer Leland Douglas.
Go to Full Review
Erik Childress
Movie Madness Podcast
Dec 1, 2024
2.4
Hard to get on board with a relatively worn plot like this when the protagonist feels like an AI version of the typical Ben Stiller character and a script that should have been repurposed to fit the climax that now arrives like a complete afterthought.
Go to Full Review