Marya E. Gates
Cool People Have Feelings, Too. (Substack)
Mar 29, 2025
It’s goofy and bleak and perfect.
Go to Full Review
Dave Giannini
InSession Film
Feb 23, 2024
In a movie full of darkness, Elaine May is a pure light giving just enough to change Henry from pitch dark to just a slight amount of gray. Enough to care for her and enough to make us believe it.
Go to Full Review
Dennis Harvey
48 Hills
Sep 12, 2022
A New Leaf comingles 1930s screwball, 1940s Preston Sturges, and 1950s Ealing comedies to uneven but sometimes sublime results.
Go to Full Review
Molly Haskell
Village Voice
Apr 20, 2022
The picture as it now stands is very funny indeed, but more charming than uproarious, and quite surprisingly romantic.
Go to Full Review
Susan Stark
Detroit Free Press
Feb 10, 2022
Maybe you can't even remember the last time you saw a purely lovable movie. A New Leaf, Elaine May's airy romantic comedy about a penniless bon vivant's pursuit of a gentle but very wealthy frump, will refresh your memory.
Go to Full Review
Gene Siskel
Chicago Tribune
Feb 10, 2022
4/4
A New Leaf is one of the funniest and most tender films I have ever seen.
Go to Full Review
Anne Louise
Contra Costa Times
Feb 10, 2022
Elaine May underplays Henrietta and steals every scene; hers is a fresh new screen talent. She directed and scripted the picture as well.
Go to Full Review
Myles Standish
St. Louis Post-Dispatch
Feb 10, 2022
[Elaine May] has written, directed and is costarred in [A New Leaf]. In it, she displays a genius tor wry and quietly zany comedy that marks her as a new force in the film field.
Go to Full Review
Joseph Gelmis
Newsday
Feb 10, 2022
A New Leaf is continuously enjoyable and frequently brilliant.
Go to Full Review
Susan Toepfer
Photoplay
Feb 10, 2022
An absolute joy.
Go to Full Review
Kevin Kelly
Boston Globe
Feb 10, 2022
Someday, perhaps. Miss May's real film will be shown but, until then, even if it is only part of what she intended, A New Leaf is a charming comedy, the best in a long, long time.
Go to Full Review
R.H. Gardner
Baltimore Sun
Feb 10, 2022
The plot, based on a short story by Jack Ritchie, is hardly new, and Miss May's handling of it falls short of brilliance. But the film does have many genuinely funny moments -- derived partly from her performance, which is admirably low-key.
Go to Full Review
Donald Miller
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Feb 10, 2022
A fresh collection of gags built on a May trademark which is the ability to see the comic aspect of relatively routine engagements.
Go to Full Review
Giles M. Fowler
Kansas City Star
Feb 10, 2022
The stars are sublimely ridiculous. Miss May herself, making her first film as writer, director and performer, has brought to the screen a brand of humor that is wickedly observant, a shade demonic and altogether fresh.
Go to Full Review
Phil Strassberg
Arizona Republic
Feb 10, 2022
There is a sense of unevenness in this otherwise funny film. But the verbal exchanges as well as the merry looks, askance and otherwise, which these two trade with one another make it hilarious much of the time.
Go to Full Review
Bernard Drew
Gannett News Service
Feb 10, 2022
It is a very funny, witty gray comedy and it's a wonderful showcase for [May's] special talents and those of Matthau.
Go to Full Review
Charles Champlin
Los Angeles Times
Feb 10, 2022
New Leaf achieves the nutty and improbable grandeur of the best movie comedies of the past. Indeed Elaine May carries us off into this crazy world of her own invention in a way that I'd come to think simply wasn't possible any more.
Go to Full Review
Joe Baltake
Philadelphia Daily News
Feb 10, 2022
It's a sporadically funny old-hat comedy with a plot that amounts to a glorified cliché.
Go to Full Review
Perry Stewart
Fort Worth Star-Telegram/DFW.com
Feb 10, 2022
It's a rare and wonderful blend of the sort of erudite belly laughs that could be elicited only Miss May and Walter Matthau.
Go to Full Review
William B. Collins
Philadelphia Inquirer
Feb 10, 2022
[A New Leaf] is a certain remedy for the glooms which currently afflict us. It is a very funny movie for most of the way.
Go to Full Review