Pauline Kael
The New Yorker
Oct 13, 2026
Stanley Kubrick had made two pictures before this one, but they were juvenilia; this shrewdly worked out suspense film, which he made at the age of 27, is the real beginning of his career.
Go to Full Review
Alan Brien
London Evening Standard
Oct 13, 2026
Written and directed by Hollywood's newest miracle boy, 27-year-old Stanley Kubrick, The Killing is a fascinating exercise in criminal craftsmanship.
Go to Full Review
Gavin Lambert
Sight & Sound
Oct 13, 2026
This shrewd, engrossing, complete-in-itself melodrama is the kind of film one had begun to think was no longer possible to make in Hollywood.
Go to Full Review
Philip K. Scheuer
Los Angeles Times
Oct 13, 2026
The Killing may be downbeat (you never met a more callous cast) but it contains some remarkable moviemaking.
Go to Full Review
Kate Cameron
New York Daily News
Oct 13, 2026
2.5/4
The Killing, based on Lionel White's novel, "The Clean Break," has enough suspense in the telling of a well-planned robbery to keep the attention of the Mayfair Theatre audience riveted on the screen.
Go to Full Review
Cyrus Durgin
Boston Globe
Oct 13, 2026
Were it not so cleverly and tautly put together, The Killing would be merely another item for the leather jacket trade... But the style is more or less the crisp method of the documentary.
Go to Full Review
Hortense Morton (Screen Scout)
San Francisco Examiner
Oct 13, 2026
Exciting and strong performances are the order of cast business. Hayden is convincing beyond the line of duty. Cook gives the most gripping portrayal as the weakling husband. One of the screen's best actors he is seen too infrequently.
Go to Full Review
Marjory Rutherford
Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Oct 13, 2026
[The Killing], produced by a new Hollywood "boy wonder," 29-year-old Stanley Kubrick, sidesteps most Hollywood crime cliches. Its criminals are not stereotypes, and its plot is full of stunning surprises.
Go to Full Review
Win Fanning
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Oct 13, 2026
The treatment of the marriage relationship between Miss Windsor and Mr. Elisha Cook can easily be considered a masterpiece in itself. It is a compelling study of the corrupt leading the easily corruptible down a crooked, sex-ridden alley.
Go to Full Review
KC Star Staff
Kansas City Star
Oct 13, 2026
In essence merely another treatment of the crime-doesn't-pay theme, The Killing reworks into a gripping and imaginative pattern a collection of characters and situations often encountered in screen recounting of lawless forays.
Go to Full Review
Des Hickey
Sunday Independent (Ireland)
Oct 13, 2026
Kubrick may be an artist in the cinema but he never forgets his duty to entertain. And as an entertainer he is astoundingly good.
Go to Full Review
Mae Tinée
Chicago Tribune
Oct 13, 2026
The thinness of the plot is almost, but not quite, covered by the cast playing an odd assortment of unattractive characters.
Go to Full Review
Paine Knickerbocker
San Francisco Chronicle
Oct 13, 2026
Produced on what Hollywood terms a shoestring, and filmed in less than a month, it has packed into its one and a half hours more satisfying suspense than is apt to be found in a far more pretentious production.
Go to Full Review
Helen Bower
Detroit Free Press
Oct 13, 2026
Good of its kind, The Killing has the realistic flavor of a documentary. It also shows how much brainwork and ingenuity that might be better be used for lawful pursuits is expended by crooks in planning a big operation.
Go to Full Review
Phil Lee
Victoria Times Colonist (B.C., Canada)
Oct 13, 2026
Director Kubrick must have been kept busier than King Farouk at Monte Carlo as he directed the sub plots and merged them with the central theme. And the gamble couldn't have been much greater.
Go to Full Review
Ann X. Smith
Newark Star-Ledger
Oct 13, 2026
It is one of those crime movies where you find yourself, in spite of all your principles, rooting for the crooks to get away with it.
Go to Full Review
Glenn C. Pullen
Cleveland Plain Dealer
Oct 13, 2026
Lucien Ballard's camera work is as gripping as the ironic action.
Go to Full Review
Mildred Martin
Philadelphia Inquirer
Oct 13, 2026
Kubrick, whose first feature film venture, Fear and Desire, marked him as a director-producer to be watched, has delivered a masterly job this time.
Go to Full Review
John Bustin
Austin American-Statesman
Oct 13, 2026
[The Killing] proves, among other things, that you can't always judge a package by its wrapping. For beneath this unpretentious exterior, you'll find one of the dandiest little screen plays of the year.
Go to Full Review
Jack Karr
Toronto Star
Oct 13, 2026
In its modest way, a little melodrama called The Killing hits the target with a lot louder thump than many of the bigger glossier members of the tribe do with their fancier resources.
Go to Full Review