Josh Parham
Next Best Picture
Jun 5, 2022
7/10
The direction is quiet yet striking in the way it captures the emotional bonds made throughout the film, particularly in its intimate scenes of passion between José and Luis.
Go to Full Review
Filipe Freitas
Always Good Movies
Apr 4, 2021
3/5
This portrayal of romantic disillusion still resonates with a good slice of honesty in defiance to an imperfect editing and some forgivable structural irregularities.
Go to Full Review
Diane Carson
KDHX (St. Louis)
May 14, 2020
José's familiar dilemma invites empathy through newcomer Enrique Salanic's complex, subtle performance.
Go to Full Review
Lisa Kennedy
Variety
Feb 18, 2020
"José" brings to light the promise of a director as compassionate as he is observant.
Go to Full Review
Peter Rainer
FilmWeek (LAist)
Feb 15, 2020
It's an evocative movie... The big problem I have is that José as a character is a bit of a blank.
Go to Full Review
Samuel R. Murrian
Parade Magazine
Feb 8, 2020
4/5
José is brutally honest about sex in a way movies seldom are. The alternately sweaty-palmed and lackadaisical buildup of online hookups, as well as the occasional, inevitable deflating disappointment of such trysts are captured just as they happen.
Go to Full Review
Godfrey Cheshire
RogerEbert.com
Feb 7, 2020
3.5/4
The satisfactions of "José" as a whole offers are considerable, and they begin with the human element.
Go to Full Review
Gary Goldstein
Los Angeles Times
Feb 7, 2020
"José" is hardly the first movie to spotlight a young person navigating their homosexuality... Nonetheless... this sophomore feature.. feels like a singular and essential entry in that subset of LGBTQ coming-of-age films with an international beat.
Go to Full Review
Joshua Brunsting
The CriterionCast
Jan 31, 2020
Li Cheng's sophomore effort is a quiet, almost neo-realist, look into life as a young gay man in conservative Guatemala that's as beautiful as it is moving.
Go to Full Review
Kristen Yoonsoo Kim
New York Times
Jan 30, 2020
The film delicately depicts the hardship of being gay in a Catholic culture and the pressure for machismo in a crime-ridden country.
Go to Full Review
Carlos Aguilar
TheWrap
Jan 29, 2020
As opposed to numerous gay-themed features from Latin America, the consequences for his characters are not violent. That's not because hatred has subsided, but because the pair has learned to suppress in order to survive.
Go to Full Review
Diego Semerene
Slant Magazine
Jan 27, 2020
2.5/4
Li Cheng gets much closer to capturing his characters' predicaments when he trusts the images alone.
Go to Full Review
Avi Offer
NYC Movie Guru
Jan 24, 2020
6.00822/10
A slow-burning and mildly engaging coming-of-age drama that's not quite as powerful nor moving as it could have been.
Go to Full Review
Gary M. Kramer
Philadelphia Gay News
May 31, 2019
[A]chingly beautiful. Audiences feel every emotion as the lens...captures the grittiness of Guatemala City, the sweat of the men's bodies and the palpable sense of despair.... A rich, involving film, "José" is not to be missed.
Go to Full Review
Kevin Ritchie
NOW Toronto
May 24, 2019
2/5
The near-silent protagonist is a frustrating and distancing art-house cliché.
Go to Full Review
Rubén Rosario
MiamiArtZine
Apr 19, 2019
Cheng's sophomore feature unfolds in episodic fashion, allowing the filmmaker to focus on quotidian interactions between his protagonist and those he cares about.
Go to Full Review
Manuel Betancourt
Remezcla
Apr 9, 2019
It makes a fascinating companion to fellow queer Guatemalan film, Temblores.
Go to Full Review
Rich Cline
Shadows on the Wall
Feb 28, 2019
4/5
Earthy and honest... Both Salanic and Herrera deliver such off-handed performances that the audience often feels like voyeurs.
Go to Full Review
Fionnuala Halligan
Screen International
Feb 28, 2019
Cheng's touching debut was made after years of research into the gay networks of South America, and the effort shows in a quiet, reflective film.
Go to Full Review
Amber Wilkinson
Eye for Film
Sep 6, 2018
3/5
Although the story is slight, Cheng treats the subject matter with care, allowing a slow but certain heat to build between José and Luis
Go to Full Review