Grant Watson Fiction Machine Aug 2, 2022 6/10

Quality dressings can distract from, but never disguise, a weak body.

Go to Full Review

Gene Siskel Chicago Tribune May 24, 2019 3.5/4

Music scholars have challenged the film's authenticity, but they cannot dispute the magnificent image-making by director Bernard Rose.

Go to Full Review

Michael Wilmington Chicago Tribune May 24, 2019 2.5/4

It may be a cartoon. Yet, with Beethoven's compositions crashing and storming around him, it's a cartoon that has some dark, harrowing grandeur.

Go to Full Review

David Sterritt Christian Science Monitor May 24, 2019

The results are always excessive and sometimes quite aggravating, but they're weirdly appropriate to the subject of the story, an over-the-top artiste who seemed excessive and aggravating to many of his 19th-century cronies.

Go to Full Review

Malcolm L. Johnson Hartford Courant May 24, 2019 2.5/4

Despite Oldman's powers, this adds up to a less than immortal musical love story.

Go to Full Review

Kenneth Turan Los Angeles Times May 24, 2019

Yes, this is another one of Hollywood's silly symphonies, an unintentionally amusing bit of piffle that allows mortals a privileged glimpse into the private life of a legendary composer.

Go to Full Review

People Staff People Magazine May 24, 2019

Ultimately, Beloved has all the sound and fury of Beethoven's music but none of its emotional resonance.

Go to Full Review

Sky Staff Sky Cinema May 24, 2019 2/5

Puffed up and pompous, but puny, this is a stodgy pudding of a film that moves at a snail's pace and tries unsuccessfully to accommodate wildly different performing styles from actors of various countries.

Go to Full Review

Jay Boyar Orlando Sentinel May 24, 2019

Moments like these may lift Immortal Beloved high enough for even the most skeptical of purists to forgive it. Moments like these and, of course, all that glorious music.

Go to Full Review

Roger Hurlburt South Florida Sun-Sentinel May 24, 2019

Immortal Beloved is pure historical hokum. Nevertheless, it is an absorbing motion picture and a heady blend of stellar performances, spectacular backdrops and crafty screenwriting.

Go to Full Review

Stephen Hunter Baltimore Sun May 24, 2019 2/4

Da-da-da-DUMB!

Go to Full Review

David Parkinson Radio Times May 24, 2019 4/5

It's an audacious mixture of Citizen Kane and Amadeus, with some Fantasia-like musical sequences added for good measure. Indeed, cinema has rarely given classical music such a chance to weave its spell.

Go to Full Review

James D. Watts Jr. Tulsa World May 24, 2019 3/4

Immortal Beloved is a lot like the famous sketch of Beethoven's study, made shortly after he died, showing a piano strewn with piles of junk and papers. It's a mess, but you know there has to be examples of Beethoven's genius in there somewhere.

Go to Full Review

Desson Thomson Washington Post May 24, 2019

For all the story's illicit passion, creative reveries, detective-like investigation and twist ending, Immortal Beloved is episodically slow and surprisingly flat.

Go to Full Review

Rita Kempley Washington Post May 24, 2019

A turgid affair with a palette that recalls used Ace bandages.

Go to Full Review

Roger Ebert Chicago Sun-Times May 24, 2019 3.5/4

There is an image in Immortal Beloved as evocative as any I can remember -- as complete as the sled in Citizen Kane, or the shadowy doorway in The Third Man.

Go to Full Review

Kevin Jackson Independent (UK) May 23, 2019

Kitsch, yes, but weirdly transporting. And the score is wonderful.

Go to Full Review

Jason Best Movie Talk Nov 16, 2014

For all the movie's faults, however, Rose does show now and then that he can create an inspired marriage of image and music.

Go to Full Review

Owen Gleiberman Entertainment Weekly Sep 7, 2011 B

As biography, Immortal Beloved is trashy and fraudulent, yet as an impressionistic riff on Beethoven's temperament, his spirit, it exerts an irresistible pull.

Go to Full Review

Kim Newman Empire Magazine Feb 4, 2009 3/5

Occasionaly the hand of Hollywood crassness is reared, but there are moments of shrewd storytelling and some fine performances.

Go to Full Review