Sean Axmaker
Stream on Demand
Sep 5, 2025
Director Alex Proyas delivers the spectacle of robots and robotic devices turning on the human detective with high-tech polish. But for all the shiny technology, he directs with a strong story sense and a narrative efficiency...
Go to Full Review
Brian Eggert
Deep Focus Review
Aug 22, 2023
1/4
Though the material possessed the potential for landmark genre filmmaking, the result feels like two hours of product placement, so-so-special FX, too much comic relief, and non-acting from a star sleeping through his performance.
Go to Full Review
Jennifer Bisset
CNET
Mar 21, 2023
A routine blockbuster for reliable entertainment.
Go to Full Review
Mike Massie
Gone With The Twins
Sep 30, 2020
7/10
The way in which the robots acrobatically leap about, as if immune to the effects of gravity, is the main offender.
Go to Full Review
Leigh Paatsch
Herald Sun (Australia)
Jun 19, 2020
3/5
Some stirring action sequences and a fascinating futuristic setting keeps things entertaining, even if this loose adaptation of the Isaac Asimov doesn't always take the most original approach possible.
Go to Full Review
Kathi Maio
The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction
Feb 28, 2020
...is it a good thing that the CGI robot was so much more interesting and believable than the (largely) human protagonist played by Will Smith? I think not. It somehow made the many shortcomings of the film seem even more apparent.
Go to Full Review
Sr. Rose Pacatte
Reel Time with Sister Rose
Apr 1, 2019
The plot seemed forced to me, though average summer fare. What bothered me the most however, was the ending.
Go to Full Review
Christopher Borrelli
Toledo Blade
Apr 1, 2019
I have seen the future and it s an episode of Frasier gone very wrong. The worst episode, actually. Not that I, Robot is a bad film; quite the contrary, it s a shamelessly entertaining video game of a narrative, directed with style and energy.
Go to Full Review
Dennis King
Tulsa World
Apr 1, 2019
3/4
...it does operate with a crisp, impressive, nuts-and-bolts efficiency as its robots do their best song-and-dance to provide us with a smooth summer diversion.
Go to Full Review
Sukhdev Sandhu
Daily Telegraph (UK)
Apr 1, 2019
Leaving aside the sub-Matrix hokum about Spooner's sweet-potato-loving grandmom, the movie humiliates itself - and embarrasses us - by the amount of time it spends plugging a glamorous car...
Go to Full Review
Richard Corliss
TIME Magazine
Apr 1, 2019
In the end, I, Robot is just an assembly-line product of a not very advanced model.
Go to Full Review
Paul Byrnes
Sydney Morning Herald
Apr 1, 2019
He excels in creating alternative worlds and the one here sustains the film, with a pristine beauty that's attractive and slightly sinister.
Go to Full Review
Joe Morgenstern
Wall Street Journal
Apr 1, 2019
This sci-fi action adventure, loosely based on the writing of Isaac Asimov, is impressive for Patrick Tatopoulos's production design but depressive for the juiceless story.
Go to Full Review
Tom Hutchinson
Radio Times
Dec 15, 2018
4/5
This may not delve as deeply as AI: Artificial Intelligence or Blade Runner, but director Alex Proyas keeps the action racing along with enough invention and thrills to make this well worth the ride.
Go to Full Review
People Staff
People Magazine
Dec 15, 2018
The problem with Robot is that it keeps reminding you of better, edgier flicks, notably Blade Runner, The Terminator and Minority Report, not to mention director Alex Proyas's own Dark City.
Go to Full Review
Megan Spencer
sbs.com.au
Dec 15, 2018
3/5
It's not as dazzling or thrilling a blend between realism and fantasy as Minority Report or even Hollow Man, but it certainly is an easy film to watch and to at times get lost in.
Go to Full Review
Peter Bradshaw
Guardian
Dec 15, 2018
2/5
[I, Robot] somehow manages to overlook the subversive potential, and it's low on wit, coming up with a good-looking but ultimately inert movie with a feeble non-ending that gave me a pain in all the diodes down my left side.
Go to Full Review
Jonathan Romney
Independent on Sunday
Dec 15, 2018
Given how hard it is to find new ideas in mainstream screen sci-fi these days, the film does a creditable job of repackaging standard speculative circuitry under a sleek new blockbuster carapace.
Go to Full Review
Andy Bailey
Screen International
Dec 15, 2018
I, Robot is far less concerned with bellowing an Orwellian socio-political warning than with giving Will Smith enough robots to bash apart and send flying across elaborate sets.
Go to Full Review
Jonathan Rosenbaum
Chicago Reader
Dec 15, 2018
It's much more of an action flick than either Metropolis or Blade Runner, but there's a provocative and visionary side to this free adaptation of Isaac Asimov's SF classic that puts it in the same thoughtful canon.
Go to Full Review