Yasser Medina
Cinefilia
Mar 25, 2025
6/10
Moss gives a remarkable, scene-stealing performance here, but unfortunately, the portrayal of the self-destructive rock star is unnecessarily long and has almost no dramatic pulse. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Brendan Cassidy
InSession Film
Jul 9, 2024
In the middle of it all is Elisabeth Moss in a decade-defining performance, simultaneously just as unhinged as it is beautiful...
Go to Full Review
Vadim Rizov
Filmmaker Magazine
Jan 5, 2023
In short: I liked the movie, and didn’t find it nearly as trying as its quickly-developing reputation would suggest.
Go to Full Review
Prahlad Srihari
Firstpost
Aug 5, 2022
As a punk rocker, Elisabeth Moss is insufferable yet irresistible in Alex Ross Perry’s sustained anxiety attack of a movie.
Go to Full Review
Merryn Johns
Curve
May 20, 2022
Her Smell is both intoxicating and nightmarish, perfectly capturing the feeling of being in the orbit of such a histrionic and toxic creature. You want to leave and yet somehow you don’t want to miss what happens next.
Go to Full Review
Taylor Baker
Drink in the Movies
Oct 4, 2021
60/100
Episode 41: Best of 2019 So Far
Go to Full Review
Katherine McLaughlin
VODzilla.co
Mar 13, 2021
9.3/10
Elisabeth Moss is exquisite in Alex Ross Perry's surprising and genuinely moving portrait of a fictional 90s punk singer.
Go to Full Review
Jesse Hassenger
Nylon
Feb 4, 2021
B
Perry stages the movie not like a biopic, but like a distended, sometimes punishing version of the micro-biography structure that's become popular over the course of the decade.
Go to Full Review
Dennis Harvey
48 Hills
Oct 21, 2020
It's like Vox Lux with less makeup and no stage choreography-a masochistic wallow in another well-acted but repellant personality whose music isn't all that inviting, either.
Go to Full Review
Matthew St. Clair
Cinema Sentries
Sep 25, 2020
While the film as a whole is exemplary, it's Moss's performance that single handedly makes it one of the year's best.
Go to Full Review
Leigh Paatsch
Herald Sun (Australia)
Sep 11, 2020
3/5
There is only one sticking point here, and it could be a deal breaker for some: the running time is a way too excessive 130 minutes-plus.
Go to Full Review
Matt Cipolla
Film Monthly
Jul 27, 2020
4/5
It may crumble under pacing issues and a total cop out of an ending, but Her Smell has more than enough flashes of wonder and a stellar lead performance.
Go to Full Review
Ben Sachs
Chicago Reader
Mar 10, 2020
There have been plenty of movies about self-destructive rock musicians, but none quite like this.
Go to Full Review
Neal Pollack
Book & Film Globe
Jan 29, 2020
2/5
The movie refuses to present a conventional narrative. Instead, it gives us a half-dozen Very Long Scenes full of nervous energy and self-importance.
Go to Full Review
Dennis Schwartz
Dennis Schwartz Movie Reviews
Jan 9, 2020
B
Lunatic '90's indie punk rocker movie that's not likable but difficult to reject.
Go to Full Review
Marlow Stern
The Daily Beast
Dec 23, 2019
Elisabeth Moss is a force of nature in Alex Ross Perry's riotous five-act drama. If there were any justice in the world she'd be an Oscar lock.
Go to Full Review
Claudia Puig
FilmWeek (LAist)
Sep 27, 2019
There's a claustrophobic, almost airless feeling to this -- it's almost suffocating, but it's always compelling.
Go to Full Review
Shikhar Verma
High on Films
Sep 25, 2019
4/5
The film ultimately becomes a parable of understanding the fact that togetherness can save more than one soul and every scene that comes in the last act is a testament to longing, change, and growth.
Go to Full Review
Amelia Harvey
The People's Movies
Sep 9, 2019
3/5
When you take away the raw aesthetics and fantastic performances Her Smell is a rather ordinary tale. Becky's journey and growth don't break the cinematic boundaries, as much as it wants to.
Go to Full Review
Joel Mayward
Cinemayward
Aug 24, 2019
2/5
Like its lead character, Alex Ross Perry's Her Smell is a chaotic, draining mess, an emotional rollercoaster where they forgot to buckle the safety belts.
Go to Full Review