John Huddy
Miami Herald
Jun 16, 2022
An old fashioned, rousing musical with some of the most spectacular singing and dancing numbers ever filmed.
Go to Full Review
TIME Staff
TIME Magazine
Apr 2, 2019
It relies almost exclusively on the celebrated eyes, ears, nose and throat of Streisand. Her musicianship remains irreproachable. But her mannerisms are so arch and calculated that one half expects to find a key implanted in her back.
Go to Full Review
David Parkinson
Empire Magazine
Apr 2, 2019
3/5
Emphasis has been placed on extravaganza, when it should really have been placed on getting good performances out of a talented cast.
Go to Full Review
Josh Larsen
LarsenOnFilm
Apr 2, 2019
2/4
...fares best with the ensemble dance numbers that elegantly combine group movement and individual footwork.
Go to Full Review
TV Guide Staff
TV Guide
Mar 26, 2019
It's an exercise in star turns, surrounded by elephantine blandness.
Go to Full Review
Robert Cushman
The Spectator
Mar 26, 2019
Hello, Dolly! is only the fourth best screen musical of 1969, and I find that a relaxing thought.
Go to Full Review
Pat Graham
Chicago Reader
Mar 26, 2019
Gene Kelly directed, a long way from Terpsichore apparently, though not, alas, from the Thanksgiving turkey.
Go to Full Review
Tony Sloman
Radio Times
Mar 26, 2019
4/5
The design, use of colour and, particularly, the marvellous score are quite breathtaking.
Go to Full Review
Sky Staff
Sky Cinema
Mar 26, 2019
4/5
[Barbra Streisand] was really too young for the role... But she was certainly in fine voice, making more of the songs by Jerry Herman than did Herman himself.
Go to Full Review
Scott Nash
Three Movie Buffs
Mar 18, 2019
2.5/4
This is a flawed movie, there's no question of that, but at the same time there are some enjoyable moments.
Go to Full Review
Tim Brayton
Antagony & Ecstasy
Aug 27, 2014
4/10
For all its failures in other areas - a bloated, heavy farce, or a character comedy full of generally tedious cartoons - its abysmal shortcomings as a musical are the saddest.
Go to Full Review
Nell Minow
Common Sense Media
Dec 24, 2010
5/5
A magical, old-fashioned musical.
Go to Full Review
Phil Hall
IdentityTheory
Dec 15, 2009
5/5
It is a work of great entertainment, a product of an era when people looked up at a screen and saw movies instead of cinema.
Go to Full Review
Variety Staff
Variety
Mar 26, 2009
Streisand is a unique performer, with that inborn vitality which marks great personalities.
Go to Full Review
Emanuel Levy
EmanuelLevy.Com
Mar 24, 2009
C
Inexplicably nominated for Oscars, Gene Kelly's last musical is a big, bloated, stagy film--despite the presence, charm and voice of Barbra Streisand.
Go to Full Review
Don Willmott
Filmcritic.com
Oct 18, 2008
2/5
The movie creaks along to its happy ending, ultimately suffocating under way too many layers of brocade, velvet, and ostrich feathers.
Go to Full Review
Michael W. Phillips, Jr.
Goatdog's Movies
Feb 19, 2007
2.5/5
It doesn't escape the overproduction trap, not by a long shot.
Go to Full Review
Paul Taylor
Time Out
Jun 24, 2006
The Jerry Herman score is unmemorable, Michael Kidd's choreography is foreshortened to accommodate yards of additional dialogue by Ernest Lehman, and the rest is Streisand capably doing her thing in a series of plushily colossal sets.
Go to Full Review
Vincent Canby
New York Times
May 9, 2005
[Director Gene Kelly and produce Ernest Lehmann] have been reverential to the point of idiocy, since, by preserving something basically thin and often witless on a large movie screen, they have merely inflated the faults to elephantine proportions.
Go to Full Review
Jeffrey Westhoff
Northwest Herald (Crystal Lake, IL)
Jan 7, 2005
2/5
Go to Full Review