Calum Baker
Radio Times
Nov 19, 2024
3/5
A competent and watchable two hours, but the ground it covers has been better trod elsewhere.
Go to Full Review
Erik Childress
Movie Madness Podcast
Oct 22, 2024
0.5/4
There have been some embarrassing biopics over time but this, a feature length version of Behind the Music recreations, is hackneyed in at best, laughable at times and shockingly shallow in engaging with the most basic sins of the entire deception.
Go to Full Review
Linda Cook
OurQuadCities / WHBF-TV (Illinois)
Sep 15, 2024
4 STARS
It's the best movie you never heard of, and one of the best of 2024.
Go to Full Review
Dennis Schwartz
Dennis Schwartz Movie Reviews
Aug 25, 2024
C
I found little interest in this uninteresting musical biopic of living a lie.
Go to Full Review
Frank Swietek
One Guy's Opinion
Aug 24, 2024
B
Without accepting the movie as gospel, you can appreciate the vitality with which it depicts an odd episode in pop music history that continues to resonate despite its essentially trivial nature.
Go to Full Review
Michael Cook
KLRT-TV
Aug 23, 2024
9/10
This a fantastic film. It's inventive and the two lead actors are perfectly cast. Even though you know what's gonna happen at the end, you still hope they make it because these two lead actors are so charismatic. This is one of the better music biopics.
Go to Full Review
Pat Padua
Spectrum Culture
Aug 21, 2024
50/100
Girl, you know it’s a lie; if only it were a lie told with more flair.
Go to Full Review
Ruth Maramis
FlixChatter Film Blog
Aug 14, 2024
3.5/5
The breaking-the-fourth-wall approach adds a cool twist without making a mockery of the subject matter. In portraying the biggest frauds in pop history, Njie & Ali performances are wonderfully authentic.
Go to Full Review
Carla Hay
Culture Mix
Aug 13, 2024
The biopic Girl You Know It's True has both tawdriness and gravitas in chronicling the rise and fall of lip-syncing pop duo Milli Vanilli. Some scenes are very rushed, but the acting is solid and there's some satirical comedy that's handled well.
Go to Full Review
Johnny Loftus
Decider
Aug 13, 2024
Girl You Know It’s True is structurally sound and satisfactory as a rise and fall-type music biopic. But the film finds a deeper note of sensitivity in its portrayal of Rob Pilatus and Fabrice Morvan.
Go to Full Review
Sabina Dana Plasse
Film Threat
Aug 13, 2024
7/10
Surprisingly mesmerizing for an already-known outcome.
Go to Full Review
Glenn Kenny
New York Times
Aug 12, 2024
Viewers who press play with intent to scoff may be surprised with how genuinely caught up they become.
Go to Full Review
Alan French
FandomWire
Aug 9, 2024
7/10
Music biopics rarely rise above mediocrity. They’re often confined to retelling an artist’s Wikipedia entries. Girl You Know It’s True leans into the muck, forcing the audience to engage with the triumphs and tragedy of Milli Vanilli.
Go to Full Review
Jennie Kermode
Eye for Film
Aug 9, 2024
4/5
Njie and Ali embrace their roles with gusto.
Go to Full Review
Mike McGranaghan
Aisle Seat
Aug 9, 2024
2/4
What we get is a truthful, yet shallow accounting of the Milli Vanilli saga without much commentary on what it all means.
Go to Full Review
Jonathan W. Hickman
The Newnan Times-Herald
Aug 9, 2024
7/10
It’s the kind of music biopic that gets the tone and structure right, making it superior to other efforts like “Back to Black."
Go to Full Review
Todd Jorgenson
Cinemalogue
Aug 9, 2024
The screenplay is derivative, but the stylish film is a compelling reconsideration of the band’s trivial legacy.
Go to Full Review
Stephen Silver
The SS Ben Hecht
Aug 9, 2024
3/5
The new biopic about the early-‘90s music scandal would be fresher if there hadn’t just been a documentary about the same thing.
Go to Full Review
Louisa Moore
Screen Zealots
Aug 9, 2024
You may think a biopic based on disgraced 80s pop duo Milli Vanilli would have very limited appeal, but this one turns out to be a riveting exploration of fame, greed, and deception that captures the seductive allure of stardom and the pitfalls of fame.
Go to Full Review
Mark Dujsik
Mark Reviews Movies
Aug 9, 2024
3/4
Writer/director Simon Verhoeven's biography of the pair and the scandal surrounding them is a subtly subversive bit of storytelling.
Go to Full Review