André Bazin
Esprit
Jun 13, 2023
Rossellini is perhaps the only filmmaker in the world who knows how to get us interested in an action while leaving it in its objective con- text. Our emotion is thus rid of all sentimentality, for it has been filtered by force through our intelligence.
Go to Full Review
Matt Brunson
Film Frenzy
Nov 3, 2021
3/4
Utterly pessimistic in every regard.
Go to Full Review
Luis Fernando Galván
En Filme
Nov 23, 2020
5/5
The images of the city are extraordinary. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Fernando F. Croce
CinePassion
Aug 11, 2014
An unrelenting searchlight and a humane act of commiseration
Go to Full Review
David Denby
The New Yorker
May 20, 2014
The colossal rubble of Berlin is not just an analogue to the collapse of the social order but an amazing sight, and the movie makes you feel the weight of every smashed faade and fallen stone.
Go to Full Review
Kim Newman
Empire Magazine
May 20, 2014
3/5
Short and very downbeat, this hits the irony buttons rather too much but is still an uncomfortable, powerful film.
Go to Full Review
David Parkinson
Radio Times
May 20, 2014
4/5
The documentary footage of a decimated Berlin is still enormously powerful, especially when compared to the coverage of that other vanquished, but unscathed, capital in Rome, Open City.
Go to Full Review
Cole Smithey
ColeSmithey.com
Jan 21, 2014
A+
[VIDEO ESSAY] In war, Rossellini seems to say, it is the innocent that suffer most.
Go to Full Review
Megan Carrigy
Senses of Cinema
Jul 30, 2010
While mainstream reportage operates all kinds of cliched evasions, Rossellini's cinematic experimentation enables us as spectators to develop our capacity for compassion. And we need this at the present time, perhaps more than ever.
Go to Full Review
James Kendrick
Q Network Film Desk
Feb 5, 2010
3.5/4
Even if you don't entirely buy into the final moments (which I didn't), they do little to lessen the power and profundity of the film's overall message about what a world at war does to those caught in the crossfire
Go to Full Review
Christopher Long
Movie Metropolis
Jan 17, 2010
8/10
Though war has ended, ideology endures. Carpet bombing cant bury a generation of poisonous lies.
Go to Full Review
Variety Staff
Variety
Mar 26, 2009
Pic isn't acted but 'lived.' Pro and non-pro cast play it with uniform sincerity. Edmund Meschke is the most impressive of the lot, delivering a poignant, believable portrayal as the young disgraced hero.
Go to Full Review
Don Macpherson
Time Out
Jun 24, 2006
A horror movie that declines to tease.
Go to Full Review
Bosley Crowther
New York Times
Mar 25, 2006
The sum effect of the presentation is a sense of bleak discomfort and despair, unrelieved by any purge of the emotions.
Go to Full Review
Dennis Schwartz
Dennis Schwartz Movie Reviews
Feb 21, 2006
B-
A horror movie in the manner of a neo-realist film, where fantasy mixes with reality.
Go to Full Review
Emanuel Levy
EmanuelLevy.Com
Jun 14, 2005
5/5
Go to Full Review
Matt Bailey
Not Coming to a Theater Near You
Feb 23, 2004
5/5
Go to Full Review
Jeffrey M. Anderson
San Francisco Examiner
Aug 7, 2003
5/5
Quickly makes you forget its soapbox agenda and delves into a deeply felt story so powerful it hurts.
Go to Full Review
Pablo Villaça
Cinema em Cena
Jul 25, 2003
5/5
Fantstico drama sobre a situao do ps-guerra, cria um personagem verossmil e sua tragdia ilustra com dor o que era viver na Alemanha naquela poca.
Go to Full Review
Gabe Leibowitz
Film and Felt
Jul 22, 2003
4/4
There's rarely a shot that doesn't portray the utter hopelesness of Edmund's situation, and it makes his eventual fate feel almost inevitable, if no less wrenching as a result.
Go to Full Review