Anna Smith
Sight & Sound
May 14, 2026
Far from Penn’s finest work, Flag Day is ultimately so busy it becomes surprisingly boring.
Go to Full Review
Mo Muzammal
Vague Visages
Jul 27, 2023
Flag Day refuses to ponder challenging ideas but still wants its viewers to be moved.
Go to Full Review
Javier Ocaña
El Pais (Spain)
Jun 16, 2022
A drama with little dialogue, lots of music and too much screaming,
and bogged down by Penn's directorial toolbox... full of commonplace American indie clichés from the last three decades. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Dan Bayer
Next Best Picture
May 10, 2022
4/10
It is as if Penn has taken all the worst tendencies of all the directors he's worked with over his lauded career (including his own worst instincts) and crammed them all into one film, one in which he gives yet another undeniably fantastic performance.
Go to Full Review
Joel Fisher
Battle Royale With Cheese
Mar 2, 2022
Flag Day comes across as a passion project to simultaneously boost Sean Penns profile whilst bonding with his daughter, but only the former comes across on screen.
Go to Full Review
Chris Wasser
Sunday Independent (Ireland)
Feb 4, 2022
2/5
Penn’s clumsy and confusing melodrama -- though well performed -- occasionally resembles a music video.
Go to Full Review
Matthew Bond
The Mail on Sunday (UK)
Jan 31, 2022
2/5
Sean Penn, who also directs, plays the father and casts his own real-life daughter, Dylan Penn, as the daughter. The actor being most indulged, however, turns out to be himself.
Go to Full Review
Andy Lea
Daily Express (UK)
Jan 31, 2022
2/5
While Dylan's charismatic, pared-down performance reminded me of her actress mum Robin Wright, Penn just reminded me of his shouty, showy self.
Go to Full Review
Wendy Ide
Observer (UK)
Jan 30, 2022
3/5
The Penns give committed - and in Dylan's case exposed - performances.
Go to Full Review
Edward Porter
Sunday Times (UK)
Jan 30, 2022
2/5
If there was any sort of family therapy involved in the Penns' work here, it has no interesting effect on what we see.
Go to Full Review
Brian Viner
Daily Mail (UK)
Jan 28, 2022
3/5
It's not a bad film, with faint echoes of Peter Bogdanovich's 1973 classic Paper Moon and a soundtrack of plaintive road songs that will either get your feet tapping or set your teeth on edge.
Go to Full Review
Ed Potton
The Times (UK)
Jan 28, 2022
4/5
Sean has powerful, painful scenes with Dylan, who is the spitting image of her mother, Robin Wright, and has inherited some of her poise too.
Go to Full Review
Danny Leigh
Financial Times
Jan 27, 2022
2/5
That Penn doesn't want to make a straight crime thriller is laudable - less clear is what he wants to make instead.
Go to Full Review
Alistair Harkness
Scotsman
Jan 27, 2022
3/5
Penn uses elliptical editing, Terrence Malick-style camera work and ornate voice-over to make it seem more profound than it really is.
Go to Full Review
Eddie Harrison
film-authority.com
Jan 26, 2022
5/5
...heartfelt and honest as a Bruce Springsteen song, Flag Day is a genuine return to the early directorial form of The Indian Runner and The Crossing Guard for Penn...
Go to Full Review
Olly Richards
Empire Magazine
Jan 24, 2022
2/5
Far from the best of Penn's directing work but also not the worst (The Last Face is unlikely to lose that dubious crown). Dylan emerges the most triumphant Penn from a largely boring drama.
Go to Full Review
Terry Staunton
Radio Times
Jan 20, 2022
3/5
Sean Penn and his daughter Dylan impress in the lead roles in this grim true-life drama, based on Jennifer Vogel's 2001 book about her uneasy relationship with her conman father.
Go to Full Review
Luis Martínez
El Mundo (Spain)
Jan 12, 2022
2/5
The film suffers from nearly all sensory 'Malickian' cinematic vices . [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Lynn Venhaus
PopLifeSTL
Oct 22, 2021
B+
While [actor-director Sean Penn] is especially good in the interactions with his daughter, he also lapses into proud dad behind the director's chair, perhaps a little too indulgent with camera time on Dylan. She is, though, destined for stardom.
Go to Full Review
Carlos Marañón
Cinemanía (Spain)
Oct 20, 2021
2.5/5
Everything is intense and obvious in this parallel journey of a father and a daughter in a dramatic search for peace with themselves. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review