Giuseppe Sedia
Kino Mania
Aug 10, 2023
4.5/5
Skolimowski succeeds in directing a minimalistic escape movie that enhances the physical performance of a wonderfully unrecognizable Vincent Gallo as the Taliban runaway [about] the many-sided taboo of Polish politics and the CIA’s covert operations.
Go to Full Review
Paul Whitington
Irish Independent
May 5, 2020
3/5
Once [Jerzy] Skolimowski has established his story's visual momentum, it goes precisely nowhere.
Go to Full Review
Allan Hunter
Daily Express (UK)
May 5, 2020
3/5
Tightly controlled by veteran director Jerzy Skolimowski and beautifully shot on location in Israel and Poland, Essential Killing is an exciting if wildly implausible fable.
Go to Full Review
Chris Knight
National Post
May 5, 2020
3/4
Too often in cinema, "existential" serves as code for "boring." That would be a mistaken assumption about this film from Polish director Jerzy Skolimowski.
Go to Full Review
Pat Kewley
PopMatters
May 5, 2020
4/10
The chases and fights are mostly well done, but no one is going to confuse Essential Killing with a Renny Harlin thrill ride, and the 'action', such as it is, is exhausted in the first half of the film.
Go to Full Review
Ben Sachs
Chicago Reader
May 5, 2020
It's great screen acting, as [Vincent] Gallo expressively uses his body to make it part of the film's overall design.
Go to Full Review
Scott Tobias
AV Club
May 5, 2020
B-
Essential Killing goes so far out of its way to avoid political commentary that the commentary that remains is slim, reduced to a familiar, though occasionally striking, statement on man's animal nature.
Go to Full Review
Tara Brady
Irish Times
May 5, 2020
The religious-themed inserts are incongruous in a project that so studiously sidesteps political markers and prove an unwanted distraction in the cinema.
Go to Full Review
Jasper Rees
The Arts Desk
May 5, 2020
For all its allegorical heft, it never finally shucks off the impression that it is a well-made oddity.
Go to Full Review
Todd McCarthy
IndieWire
May 5, 2020
The violent perversity of some of the man's actions throws things off to an extent and, ultimately, [Jerzy] Skolimowski's bag of narrative tricks is not ample enough to fill out even the brief running time.
Go to Full Review
Jared Mobarak
Jaredmobarak.com
May 5, 2020
6/10
It isn't as easy as I'd like with shoddy performances hurting the authenticity to make us want [Vincent] Gallo to laugh from the absurdity of it all instead of cower in fear, but we make due.
Go to Full Review
Erin Free
FILMINK (Australia)
May 5, 2020
With the mesmeric Vincent Gallo at its swirling centre, and the stark cinematography of Adam Sikora driving its often blinding imagery, Essential Killing is a stunning film.
Go to Full Review
Leslie Felperin
Variety
May 5, 2020
Despite skillful assemblage, the script's plausibility issues increasingly undermine engagement, even with the generous argument that the pic is a parable and operates according to more poetic laws of realism.
Go to Full Review
Eric Kohn
IndieWire
May 5, 2020
At times engrossing and not without palpable suspense, it nonetheless amounts to a provocative doodle.
Go to Full Review
Deborah Young
The Hollywood Reporter
May 5, 2020
Vincent Gallo, who says not a single word in the film, invests the main character with deep-seated desperation in a performance that will win kudos.
Go to Full Review
Roger Ebert
RogerEbert.com
May 5, 2020
3/4
With "Essential Killing," [Jerzy] Skolimowski comes closer than ever before to a pure, elemental story.
Go to Full Review
Stephen Saito
Moveable Fest
Jan 9, 2019
Gallo is as inscrutable as ever, game to do such things as eating ants and let his piercing eyes do the acting, exuding a fearlessness that is the pulse of the film, even if it's absent a beating heart.
Go to Full Review
Chris Fujiwara
n+1
Nov 14, 2017
Maybe the only failing of Essential Killing is that everything in it is seen so sufficiently that one doesn't feel the need to go back to watch it another time (unlike most great films, which improve on repeated viewings).
Go to Full Review
Andrew Tracy
Cinema Scope
Nov 8, 2017
Quite literally, Gallo is the only reason to see Essential Killing, and it's that which guarantees the film's blessedly quick fade from our ever more cluttered horizons.
Go to Full Review
Dennis Schwartz
Dennis Schwartz Movie Reviews
Mar 14, 2013
B-
Skolimowski's fresh approach keeps us on guard.
Go to Full Review