Luke Buckmaster Flicks (AU, NZ, UK) Aug 6, 2026

The film didn’t receive the recognition it deserved upon release, but hopefully its reputation will continue to ripen, as a rare cop movie more interested in morals than machismo.

Go to Full Review

Matt Brunson Film Frenzy Nov 26, 2025 3/4

Cop Land isn’t so much a police drama as a Western with a modern-day spin.

Go to Full Review

Don Shanahan Every Movie Has a Lesson Jul 18, 2025 4/5

Dropping his flair and charisma, raising his voice up from his usual baritone range, and slouching into his character's pathetic frame, you forget in the first five minutes that you're watching John Rambo or Rocky Balboa.

Go to Full Review

Akos Peterbencze Vulnerable Man (Medium) Jul 21, 2023

Cop Land, with its powerhouse cast and script, remains an underappreciated genre piece.

Go to Full Review

Wesley Lovell Cinema Sight Jan 7, 2023 2.5/4

“Cop Land” is an interesting film that allows its flaws to overwhelm it in the end while never realizing its full potential.

Go to Full Review

Alistair Lawrence Common Sense Media Oct 4, 2022 4/5

While the movie has its flaws -- the plot can't seem to decide whether it wants to be a detective mystery or an organized crime drama -- what has aged well is Stallone's foray into making himself vulnerable as the meek and cowardly Freddy.

Go to Full Review

Yasser Medina Cinefilia Sep 16, 2021 7/10

'Cop Land', James Mangold's second film in the director's chair, has an intrigue that keeps me hooked at all times with its plot about police corruption. [Full review in Spanish]

Go to Full Review

Rachel Wagner Rachel's Reviews (YouTube) Oct 11, 2020

Stallone's character is interesting and easy to root for

Go to Full Review

Leigh Paatsch Herald Sun (Australia) Jun 26, 2020 2.5/5

A haunting and decidedly downbeat police drama, Cop Land marks one of the few times anyone could see fit to sing Sly's praises.

Go to Full Review

Ed Travis Hollywood Jesus Apr 1, 2020

James Mangold says that his goal was to mix elements of a grand urban crime drama a la Goodfellas with westerns like High Noon. My opinion? He succeeded in spades.

Go to Full Review

Jason Bailey Flavorwire Aug 26, 2017

'Cop Land' holds up as a pretty good little thriller, a Sidney Lumet movie in a Martin Scorsese movie's clothing.

Go to Full Review

Kevin Carr 7M Pictures Aug 15, 2012 4/5

not your traditional action flick, nor your traditional cop flick. It has elements of each, all wrapped up in a new type of story that drips in realism and gray characters.

Go to Full Review

Owen Gleiberman Entertainment Weekly Apr 9, 2008 B-

Mangold certainly knew what he was doing when he cast Keitel and De Niro.

Go to Full Review

David Edelstein Slate Apr 9, 2008

Cop Land shares its leading man's slow-wittedness, but also his likability.

Go to Full Review

Jack Kroll Newsweek Apr 9, 2008

Mangold is something of a pseudo-Scorsese.

Go to Full Review

Ian Freer Empire Magazine Apr 9, 2008 3/5

A good effort, but the star power on show throws the proceedings off kilter somewhat, hiking up an expectation that the film ultimately cannot live up to.

Go to Full Review

Paul Tatara CNN.com Apr 9, 2008

It's pretty funny, actually, that Stallone gained 40 pounds to play this role, and what the movie needs more than anything else is to eat a salad and do some sit-ups.

Go to Full Review

Sandra Contreras TV Guide Apr 9, 2008 3/4

It sizzles toward an explosive and satisfying climax in which everything -- Stallone included -- fully bursts into life.

Go to Full Review

Todd McCarthy Variety Apr 9, 2008

Although too simplistic in its good-guys/bad-guys approach to morally and emotionally ambiguous material, Cop Land emerges as an absorbing and dramatic yarn about exposing the evil doings of some of New York's finest.

Go to Full Review

Stephen Hunter Washington Post Apr 9, 2008

At its heart, the movie has a good story to tell: the lumbering oaf who's not nearly as stupid and not nearly as gutless as all the hot dogs from the big city think.

Go to Full Review