Matt Brunson
Film Frenzy
Dec 6, 2025
4/4
The best picture of 2010, Darren Aronofsky’s Black Swan is a messy masterpiece.
Go to Full Review
Patrick Cavanaugh
The Wolfman Cometh
Sep 11, 2025
4/5
Natalie Portman and Darren Aronofsky are collaborating at the top of their game for this terrifying, gorgeous, and bewildering descent into madness.
Go to Full Review
Gayle Sequeira
BFI
Aug 27, 2025
Doubles, mirror images and unnerving doppelgängers dot this tale of a repressed, rigid ballerina (Natalie Portman), whose artistic director pushes her to lose herself in her art during a production of Tchaikovsky’s Swan Lake. Instead, she loses her head.
Go to Full Review
Trace Thurman
Horror Queers Podcast
Mar 11, 2025
4.5/5
Darren Aronofsky's beautiful, haunting tale of obsession takes a look at the lengths some will go to achieve perfection. What luck that Portman has achieved just that in her performance.
Go to Full Review
Dan Bayer
Next Best Picture
Aug 8, 2024
9/10
“Black Swan” stands as proof that films have been elevating horror to the level of art for decades, and when they get it right, the results are exhilarating.
Go to Full Review
Michael Leader
Den of Geek
May 7, 2024
4/5
Throughout, we can spot thematic threads from Aronofsky's body of emotionally raw, character-based studies of obsession and tragedy.
Go to Full Review
Don Shanahan
Every Movie Has a Lesson
Feb 16, 2024
5/5
The film's slow-boiling pull on you, the audience, builds more and more with a pace and tension that matches the maddening breakdowns of its lead character.
Go to Full Review
Yasser Medina
Cinefilia
Feb 15, 2024
8/10
Its psychological dialectic is as terrifying as it is paranoid with Portman's formidable performance. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Brian Eggert
Deep Focus Review
Aug 3, 2023
3/4
Black Swan warrants a profound response both from its stark melodramatic turns and from the sheer authority behind its artistic ambitions.
Go to Full Review
Amy Thomasson
InSession Film
Apr 26, 2023
Aronofsky [is] a master filmmaker...
Go to Full Review
Rob Gonsalves
Rob's Movie Vault
Oct 4, 2022
C
A high-pitched affair that sometimes risks silliness and sometimes achieves it. The risk is important — the movie is nothing if not impassioned — but overall the film is too rigidly schematic to be truly wild.
Go to Full Review
Rene Jordan
El Nuevo Herald (Miami)
Jul 15, 2022
Natalie Portman, with almost supernatural fragility often saves this hyper melodrama. [Full review in Spanish]
Go to Full Review
Sean Axmaker
Stream on Demand
Jul 5, 2022
'Red Shoes' meets 'Repulsion' in Darren Aronofsky’s... jittery psychological portrait of neurosis and obsession in a meek, repressed young woman who still has little girl prima ballerina dreams.
Go to Full Review
Julie and Brandy
Autostraddle
Aug 31, 2021
What were they trying to say? What happened?... You're all pretending you know what it means.
Go to Full Review
Jason Adams
My New Plaid Pants
Jul 2, 2021
A
Aronofsky wants you to feel that heroin oozing into your vein, he wants you to feel that barbed wire and glass burrowing under your tights, and here he wants you go right off the deep end with a girl in a tutu
Go to Full Review
Aviva Dove-Viebahn
Ms. Magazine
Jun 24, 2021
Black Swan is a top-form thriller-visceral, moving, and stunningly beautiful-but it's also a film about the darkness our own minds conjure up when we're overwhelmed by ambition.
Go to Full Review
Phoenix Danger
Autostraddle
Jun 8, 2021
The impeccable casting adds an elevated element of reality to a film that already hits so close to home.
Go to Full Review
James McMahon
NME (New Musical Express)
May 25, 2021
4/5
While there are few films that with look and sound as good as this as 2011 plays out, there'll will be even less that will be so misunderstood. Black Swan is a hoot. A silly, melodramatic hoot.
Go to Full Review
Dustin Chang
Floating World
Mar 21, 2021
Black Swan is way over the top (not that his films were ever subtle) in saint/whore dichotomy with bombastic Swan Lake score. But it fits with visceral visuals creating internal chaos in the character.
Go to Full Review
Mark Jackson
Epoch Times
Feb 20, 2021
4/5
Director Darren Aronofsky has done an excellent service by showing how art has reached the extreme of a downward demonic trend. Now that we've reached that extreme, perhaps, like the yin-yang symbol, things will turn around.
Go to Full Review