Rotten Tomatoes
Suggestions will appear as you start typing. Submit search Movies Tv shows RT App New News Showtimes

The Black Dahlia

Play trailer Poster for The Black Dahlia R,  2006,  2h 1m,  Mystery & Thriller/ Crime/ Drama Play Trailer Watchlist
Stream Now Watchlist 32% 191 Reviews Tomatometer 27% 50,000+ Ratings Popcornmeter
32% Tomatometer 191 Reviews 27% Popcornmeter 50,000+ Ratings
Two cops in the 1940s Los Angeles investigate the murder of a Hollywood starlet (Mia Kirshner), and one (Aaron Eckhart) puts his marriage in jeopardy by obsessing over the crime, while the other (Josh Hartnett) becomes involved with a woman (Hilary Swank) from a prominent family, who happens to have an unsavory tie to the victim.
Watch on Fandango Stream Now

Where to Watch

The Black Dahlia

Stream

Rent The Black Dahlia on Fandango, or buy it on Fandango.

The Black Dahlia

What to Know

Critics Consensus

Though this ambitious noir crime-drama captures the atmosphere of its era, it suffers from subpar performances, a convoluted story, and the inevitable comparisons to other, more successful films of its genre.

Read Critics Reviews

Critics Reviews

View More
Brian Tallerico UGO Mar 24, 2007
You have to wonder just how vibrant the film would have been during the Reagan or Clinton administration, when De Palma was in his prime. Go to Full Review
Marc Savlov Austin Chronicle Sep 30, 2006
1.5/5
Forty-five minutes in, I was already glancing at my watch and wondering why the only lively actress in this film was playing the dead girl. Go figure. Go to Full Review
Nathan Rabin AV Club Sep 23, 2006
A-
The pairing of Ellroy and De Palma proves a marriage made in hardboiled heaven. Go to Full Review
Joe Lipsett Murder Made Fiction Podcast - Bloody Disgusting May 19, 2026
2.5/5
A curious, but good looking mess. Hilary Swank and Fiona Shaw steal every scene, but the competing storylines don't often mesh well. The film should have just pulled the trigger on the central throuple Go to Full Review
Noah Berlatsky Splice Today May 22, 2025
De Palma should be the perfect choice to helm a seedy neo-noir, but the script meanders, and the director ends up turning a story of greed, lust, and betrayal into an exercise in tedious moralism. Go to Full Review
Yasser Medina Cinefilia Nov 17, 2024
6/10
De Palma pours some of his aesthetic adjustments on it, but unfortunately its narrative often loses track of police intrigue and remains situated in common places in its uchronia about The Black Dahlia's nefarious murder case. [Full review in Spanish] Go to Full Review
Read all reviews

Audience Reviews

View More
Ron R Feb 25, 2019 A movie that had no direction and very little substance, I was bored and had no idea what was even happening. What angered me about it was how stylish this movie thought it was. See more
Finn L Dec 16, 2018 Der Mordfall der schwarzen Dahlie, in einem Stil des Film Noir! Regisseur Brian De Palma nimmt uns mit, ins Jahr 1947, der Stadt der Engel. Zwei abgehalfterte Boxer und beste Freunde des Police Departements, jagen Mafiabosse, Kleinkriminelle und korrupte Polizisten. Als sie zum dem Fall der schwarzen Dahlie stossen, gehen die zwei Freunde an ihre Grenzen. Eigentlich ist der Thriller stimmig, wenn De Palma, die Geschichte, etwas tiefgründiger erzählt hätte. Die Story kommt nicht voran und auch die Figuren bleiben schwach und langweilig. Die Figur des Helden Bucky Bleichert wird von Josh Hartnett dargestellt. Man findet aber, dass Hartnett etwas überfodert mit seiner Rolle ist. Hartnett spielt seine Rolle, wirkt aber angespannt. Auch die selbstsichere Scarlett Johansson wirkt hier eher blass und hilfesuchend, in ihrer Rolle. Die zwei besten Rollen haben Aaron Eckhart, der seine Rolle als Lee Blanchard genüsslich an die Grenzen spielt und Hilary Swank, die eine mysteriöse Femme Fatale personifiziert. Auch die Kamera sind gut positioniert und gehen mit dem Geschehen mit. Kein Wunder wurde Kameramann Vilmos Zsigmond hier für den Oscar nominiert. Denn der Blickwinkel ist hier nicht nur auf das Allgemeine gerichtet, sondern fokussiert hier auch die Gesichter der einzelnen Personen, von denen man nicht weiss, auf welcher Seite des Gesetzes sie stehen. Das Drehbuch schrieb hier James Ellroy. Er mischte eigentlich der reale Fall der schwarzen Dahlie mit etwas Fiction der Filmindustrie. Im Film wurde der Mörder auch gestellt. In Wahrheit aber, wurde der Fall Black Dahlia niemals aufgeklärt. Auch wenn es so ist, dass die Geschichte aufgeklärt wurde, bleibt das Ganze weitgehend zurück und der Verlauf des Films, läuft mit angezogener Handbremse. Fazit: Man ist besseres von De Palma gewohnt. Ein guter Thriller nur leider nicht ganz spannend umgesetzt! See more
Leia L Oct 16, 2018 Who's the biggest fool; DePalma for making the movie or me for wasting two hours of my life?
Harry S Jun 29, 2018 I'd basically given up on Brian De Palma long ago, so I'm not sure why I checked this out from the library. Perhaps it was the promise of "neo-noir", drawn from the same vein as L.A. Confidential (also based on James Ellroy's work), a far superior film? Or maybe I just needed something trashy after life got too serious? De Palma was always trashy, even when his films had some merit (long ago), but, unfortunately, he got boring. This film is boring despite its star power. Josh Hartnett is a rather vacuous hero, not charismatic enough to carry the picture, and seemingly lost in the plot twists rather than actively engaging with them. (Sure, that's a traditional noir hero conundrum but we needed more of an active problem-solver like Bogey, Dick Powell, or Glenn Ford here rather than a passive "baby, I don't care" Mitchum-type who gets suckered). Scarlett Johansson tries her hand at the forties femme fatale but I've concluded that she can't really act. Hilary Swank can act and seems cast against type as another femme fatale but her part of the plot feels rather ludicrous. Aaron Eckhart, as the somewhat shady cop/partner to Hartnett, plays cartoonish, perhaps trying to will the film to be bolder than it is. I suspect the underlying book, based on a true crime story (the real murder of a wannabe actress in the days of Hollywood's golden age), is a lot more interesting and the many characters and intricate/convoluted plot are done justice in a way that De Palma just can't manage to put on the screen. Even the Oscar-nominated cinematography by Vilmos Zsigmond can't rescue things. See more
Albus P Feb 14, 2018 I loved the book but found the ending ridiculous. The film is consistently ridiculous but starts out compellingly so. De Palma can make enthralling camp so I tried to delay judgement. What ended up on screen is a mess. It never captures the spirit of Ellroy but is impeccably realized visually. The actors are not served well, neither is the source material. It's close to being so bad it's good but it doesn't quite succeed on that front either. It's an interesting curio for DePalma/Ellroy fans. See more
Theodore W Mar 11, 2017 Confusing story, but pretty interesting I think. I like the noire style of the film.
Read all reviews
The Black Dahlia

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING

The Black Dahlia

View more videos
Syriana 73% 67% Syriana Watchlist American Beauty 87% 93% American Beauty Watchlist TRAILER for American Beauty Hustle & Flow 82% 82% Hustle & Flow Watchlist TRAILER for Hustle & Flow The Good Shepherd 56% 51% The Good Shepherd Watchlist Blood Diamond 63% 90% Blood Diamond Watchlist Discover more movies and TV shows. View More

Movie Info

Synopsis Two cops in the 1940s Los Angeles investigate the murder of a Hollywood starlet (Mia Kirshner), and one (Aaron Eckhart) puts his marriage in jeopardy by obsessing over the crime, while the other (Josh Hartnett) becomes involved with a woman (Hilary Swank) from a prominent family, who happens to have an unsavory tie to the victim.
Director
Brian De Palma
Producer
Art Linson, Moshe Diamant, Rudy Cohen
Screenwriter
Josh Friedman
Distributor
Universal Pictures
Production Co
Signature Pictures
Rating
R (Sexual Content|Language|Some Grisly Images|Strong Violence)
Genre
Mystery & Thriller, Crime, Drama
Original Language
English
Release Date (Theaters)
Sep 15, 2006, Wide
Release Date (Streaming)
May 20, 2016
Box Office (Gross USA)
$22.5M
Runtime
2h 1m
Sound Mix
Dolby SRD, DTS
Aspect Ratio
Scope (2.35:1)
Join The Newsletter Join The Newsletter Cookie Settings