David Nusair
Reel Film Reviews
Mar 13, 2026
2/4
...a somewhat misguided piece of work that’s rarely, if ever, as propulsive or stylish as its subject matter might’ve indicated...
Go to Full Review
Alexander Ryll
Gay Essential
Sep 15, 2019
The studio that released the film Miramax, ordered 40 minutes removed from the film and 30 minutes worth of reshoots. The result not only sanitized the film, but fundamentally changed the characters.
Go to Full Review
Alexandra Heller-Nicholas
Horror Nonna
Aug 25, 2018
The director's cut of 54 is a remarkable artefact that tells us as much about the 1990s as it does the 1970s.
Go to Full Review
Malcolm L. Johnson
Hartford Courant
Apr 10, 2018
2.5/4
A soapy, fictionalized chronicle of the fast times at 54.
Go to Full Review
Ray Pride
Newcity
Jul 28, 2015
The most affecting moments are shards of sexual behavior... that existed only on the samizdat VHS, the degraded quality suggesting ghostly remnants of film's scissoring [and] the long-dead behaviors on-screen, debauchery and gaucherie alike.
Go to Full Review
Glenn Dunks
Glenn Dunks
Jun 15, 2015
B+
[The Director's Cut] is out and proud, not at all shying away from the sexual aggression of Phillippe's character as he calmly removes his clothes for any gender.
Go to Full Review
Oktay Ege Kozak
The Playlist
Jun 2, 2015
B-
The director's cut still has a pacing that lags during the second act, and now that the film's about the love triangle, the scenes with Julie don't really add anything to the overall story. That being said, it deserves a second chance in its new life.
Go to Full Review
Sarah Boslaugh
Playback:stl
Mar 14, 2012
3/10
...comes off like a high-budget cautionary tale, concerned that if it shows anything attractive about Studio 54, some young and innocent viewer might be corrupted...
Go to Full Review
Emanuel Levy
Variety
Jun 18, 2008
A more critical and resonant Hollywood movie about the glorious disco culture screams to be made.
Go to Full Review
Maitland McDonagh
TV Guide
Jun 18, 2008
2.5/4
A shapeless homage to the glory that was Studio 54 in its decadent heyday...
Go to Full Review
Rob Gonsalves
Rob's Movie Vault
Jul 23, 2007
D
Let me pause for a minute to think of a more boring subject for a movie ... Sorry. I give up.
Go to Full Review
Charlotte O'Sullivan
Time Out
Jan 26, 2006
Myers exploits every vicious, self-hating line that comes his way.
Go to Full Review
Robin Clifford
Reeling Reviews
Apr 9, 2005
D-
A mish-mash of bad writing, poor acting (except Myers), amateur directing and mediocre production credits.
Go to Full Review
Garth Franklin
Dark Horizons
Mar 14, 2005
2/5
Go to Full Review
Philip Martin
Arkansas Democrat-Gazette
Jan 8, 2005
... a wasted opportunity
Go to Full Review
Dragan Antulov
rec.arts.movies.reviews
Jul 29, 2004
3/10
The 1970s were great times, but most viewers could hardly come to that conclusion based on this film.
Go to Full Review
Judith Egerton
Courier-Journal (Louisville, KY)
Jul 1, 2004
2/4
One can only hope "54" will hammer the final nail in disco's coffin. It's music that I don't want stayin' alive.
Go to Full Review
Dan Jardine
Apollo Guide
Mar 16, 2004
53/100
54 is mediocre on almost all counts: acting (with a couple of exceptions), writing, direction and cinematography are uniformly bland, inoffensive and completely unmemorable.
Go to Full Review
James Sanford
Kalamazoo Gazette
Jul 2, 2003
a nostalgic whitewash. With its sterling beat-heavy soundtrack and non-stop glitz, the movie captures the look and sound of its inspiration much more convincingly than it conjures up the Studio 54 atmosphere.
Go to Full Review
Leonard Schwarz
Palo Alto Weekly
May 20, 2003
2.5/4
Qualifies as one of the more entertaining bad movies of the year.
Go to Full Review